Scott congrats on your first decade!
Mauritius I think fits for you very well. We have numerous expats here in Saudi Arabia that fly down there for the beach alone and the husband brings his clubs. They have about 10 courses I think, my favorite is Bernard Langer's course Ile aux Cerfs, not sure if he actually designed it.
The good thing about Mauritius is that it is cheaper than the Seychelles and Maldives by quite a bit. I think the Seychelles may have a course as well, not sure, but Mauritius has wonderful beaches at about 1/2 price of Maldives. Granted they don't have the numerous private island resorts with overwater bungalows, but their beach resorts are great.
It isn't cheap necessarily, but it is compared to Maldives and much of Seychelles, plus it has golf where the others lack. Mauritius is a hidden gem for many because Maldives gets so much business because most people can't go to all three so they pick Maldives for the once in a lifetime/honeymoon destination.