News:

Welcome to the Golf Club Atlas Discussion Group!

Each user is approved by the Golf Club Atlas editorial staff. For any new inquiries, please contact us.


Jeff Schley

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: The Quarry at La Quinta
« Reply #25 on: January 20, 2018, 08:17:23 AM »
Thanks so much for the responses guys.  Irregardless of the finances required for membership and deals, and perhaps this is a separate thread so please move it to a new thread as I'm new to this forum, but what would be the top 5 private golf course designs for the Palm Springs area?  I have 2 friends, irregardless of costs, housing community, etc. I have asked this to and I'll give you their feedback (some have multiple courses thus I'll just put the club name).  I'd love to get some real golf course design aficionados opinions of PS layouts.

Robert
1. The Quarry
2. The Tradition
3. Bighorn
4. Vintage
5. Madison Club

Randy
1. Bighorn
2. Vintage
3. The Quarry
4. Stone Eagle
5. The Hideaway

Again this didn't consider anything other than the course or courses themselves, not community, cost etc. I can tell you they didn't care about walking, nor did they rate on the highest slope etc. (although interesting as I should maybe add that and the designer)

 I'm looking for a club to join that has a great layout to play over and over, I don't play tennis or worry about the extra amenities really.  Thanks so much and again if I need to make a new thread for the best Palm Springs private layouts I will.
"To give anything less than your best, is to sacrifice your gifts."
- Steve Prefontaine

Jack Carney

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: The Quarry at La Quinta
« Reply #26 on: January 20, 2018, 10:35:16 AM »
Its been several years now but I lived there for four years - played most in the area. I have been back a couple of times to play some of the new ones. IMO Stone Eagle is BY FAR the best in the area, after that I would play Quarry, Pete Dye course at Mission Hills, Nicklas Private at PGA West and I guess the Palmer Private at PGA West or Diana Shore at Mission Hills. Bighorn is a complete waste of time, unwalkable and just a waste of land.

Daryl David

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: The Quarry at La Quinta
« Reply #27 on: January 20, 2018, 04:06:22 PM »
My take
Top 5 considering quality of golf only. (Ignores club vibe, housing, costs, etc.). Privates only


1.  Quarry
2.  Stone Eagle
3.  Madison Club
4.  Vintage
5.  Big Horn


Runner ups (no order)
Plantation
Toscana
El Dorado
The Reserve
Tradition
Hideaway



« Last Edit: January 20, 2018, 04:40:09 PM by Daryl David »

John Crowley

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: The Quarry at La Quinta
« Reply #28 on: January 21, 2018, 12:41:13 AM »
My take for play day after day, good to excellent architecture alphabetical order.


Palms
Plantation
Quarry
Stone Eagle.



I Haven’t played but could possibly fit in above group.


Madison
Eldorado


Not up to play day after day standard all big on eye candy.


Toscana
Big Horn
Tradition
The Reserve
Hideaway












Peter Ferlicca

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: The Quarry at La Quinta
« Reply #29 on: January 23, 2018, 03:31:16 PM »
Palm Desert is a wonderful place in the winter time and is full of fun golf experiences.  I am obviously going to be biased towards Stone Eagle since I worked there for 5 years, but still have some different opinions on the other high end privates in the valley.  From the sounds of it, it seems like you obviously can afford the top dollar and the mid range privates don't even interest you so I will just mention the top end.

If you are looking just for the best golf experience day in and day out it is Stone Eagle, if you want to have a good club atmosphere with more than just (19 holes!) and more events going on than Quarry is your answer for that.  The Quarry has an amazing par 3 course also. 

After those as the top two choices IMO it would go in this order
Vintage- with Jackson/Kahn's most recent work on the mountain course it is a pretty stellar 36 hole combo in a great setting
Madison- from an non golf experience point of view it would be pretty hard to beat this one, any guests you would bring here would love this place, the course is very good, but still doesn't hold a candle to Stone Eagle IMO.
Tradition- One of the better properties in the valley with many holes right up against the mountain, very underrated Palmer course with a couple of double greens and a fun par 3 course.
Bighorn- 36 holes which is nice and the canyon course is a good Fazio, IMO the mountain course there is awful and I crack up when people say that is a good golf course. 
Hideaway- 36 holes, the only reason this is behind Bighorn is because it isn't near any mountains on a flat piece of property, but the golf there is pretty good.  The Dye course is very bland for Dye though.
After that it is just a bunch of clubs that is up to you on what you are looking for club and golf wise.  Palms and Plantation are almost identical and seems to me would get very boring after multiple plays.
Toscana now has 36 holes and is decent with the new 18 being more exciting IMO.
Reserve is on a nice property but isn't captivating at all.

IMO, I like to have a lot of options and PGA West Private isn't a bad club to consider with all the courses you have to rotate through. 

Jeff Schley

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: The Quarry at La Quinta
« Reply #30 on: November 17, 2018, 07:48:17 AM »
I am in love! ;D
Just played The Quarry this past week and wow, that is impressive.  As others have said, the conditioning is about as good as possible.  You can't even find a divot anywhere as they pick up all divots after each shot and put it into a divot bag (a first for me). The routing is predicated on uphill/downhill with 10 being a favorite of mine for sure and a rare beautiful uphill hole.  It was just a couple days off overseed and cartpaths only, the GM was apologetic as he said this is about the worst I could see the course. Greens were not fast (probably 9-10 at most) with the greens having mild slope to them, but very fair.  I don't recall an unfair pin placement although there weren't many flat putting areas, with some tilt to the greens.  You have to know the Palm Springs valley where everything breaks to Indio and the mountain.
The fairways were very generous considering it is a desert course, although not a true desert course for they have rough and even that is like the 1st cut at Augusta National. 

The Short Course is really unlike anything I have seen.  They have a 10 hole TF short course which are all par 3's, although three of the holes can be turned into par 4's from different tees. It is not widely photographed or publicized and the GM says they don't allow it, it is strictly for the members enjoyment. I can see why as it is visually almost overwhelming with the scenery of palm trees/ flowers/ mountains, streams, etc. Gorgeous course.  I played Hamilton Farm this summer which had the only 18 hole par 3 course rated by the USGA apparently. The Short Course exceeded that on visual eye candy alone.  Many members go and walk the short course with their dogs or just for exercise and dont' play it as much.  Almost like a nature walk and what a walk it is.
This is definitely being considered as a daily course for me to retire to in 4-5 years. The staff was welcoming as you would expect but very talkative and genuinely nice people.  The 10 or so members I met, besides being retired from their extremely successful careers, loved talking NFL football, sports, and ribbing each other.  Pretty unpretentious group, which isn't what you would think at a high end club in Palm Springs.
Also a side note is that yes they have homes on the course, but only 47 are built out of a possible 105 I believe.  more than half are on the Short Course and those on the main course are set back quite a bit, very tranquil not seeing homes.
So I admit I was very impressed and can see why the raters love it for conditioning, although it is not a difficult course by any means with a pedestrian 128 slope from the blue tees. If I was a mid to low single digit handicap it wouldn't be as challenging certainly. I don't have that problem and doubt I will when I retire. ;D
Two thumbs up for The Quarry as for the site it was built on TF did one of his best work IMO. This probably passes Galloway National for TF's I have played.
"To give anything less than your best, is to sacrifice your gifts."
- Steve Prefontaine

Tags:
Tags:

An Error Has Occurred!

Call to undefined function theme_linktree()
Back