Banchory or Ballater ?

[Niall C]

I'm going up north for a few days with friends and playing Balmoral on the first day. The question is where to stay over night afterwards and where to play the next day. The choice is either Ballater or Banchory. Anyone have any thoughts on those two ? Clearly there are other options but the choice is coming down to these to so comments on them would be appreciated.


Thanks


Niall

[Thomas Dai]

Been quite a while but i have played both quite a few times and Ballater is the better imo. I believe Ballater has a MacKenzie connection.


Tell us more in due course Niall, about Balmoral as well.


atb

[Ally Mcintosh]

Ballater certainly

[Niall C]

Thanks guys. I've played Ballater and quite enjoyed it. Not played Banchory though and was interested in finding out if it was worth the diversion. I suspect we will probably stay in Ballater as well.


Dai - Ballater does have a MacKenzie connection in that he redesigned the course and also designed a nine hole relief course that is now largely lying under the caravan park.


Niall

[Robin_Hiseman]

Ballater is certainly superior to Banchory, both in terms of design quality and setting. Banchory is still charming, but in a ten-game match Ballater has it 8-2.

[Clyde Johnson]

Not the answer to your question, but I'd stop at Dalmunzie Castle for 9 on your way-up...well worth an hour, if the sun is shining!

[Niall C]

Clyde


Absolutely. I've already suggested it but I'm not organising. Knowing the other players in the group, a couple of the par 3's at Dalmunzie might be a bit of a challenge for them in terms of carry distance. I also suggested Pitlochry both for a game and as a stop over but suspect we'll end up in Ballater which will be no hardship.


Niall

[Jon Wiggett]

Why chose Niall? The day is long enough to play an easy round at both.


Jon

[Brian_Ewen]

Niall
No doubt it is Ballater over Banchory.


Yet Banchory is worth seeing for for a few of its holes.


And if seeing quirk is your thing, then the blind uphill par 3 16th meets the criteria.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WPXOgM23Fg8

[Niall C]

Why chose Niall? The day is long enough to play an easy round at both.


Jon

Jon

Let's just say that I represent the youth policy in this fourball. I'm not sure we are even doing two rounds of the nine hole Balmoral course never mind two 18 hole courses in one day.

Brian

Thanks for that. I was hoping you would chip in. For you and others that know that area, what's the general order of courses along Deeside in terms of quality ?

Niall

[Ally Mcintosh]

Niall,


Braemar has a couple of cool holes. Aboyne has more than a couple. I'd put both ahead of Banchory but many would argue that point as Banchory tended to have a good club feel, a better budget and hence better conditioning than all of the others. Ballater wins out over all three.


Deeside has had a few too many hands making changes. Affluent membership and decent day out.


Peterculter a relatively average modern addition.

[Thomas Dai]

Braemar has a couple of cool holes. Aboyne has more than a couple. I'd put both ahead of Banchory but many would argue that point as Banchory tended to have a good club feel, a better budget and hence better conditioning than all of the others. Ballater wins out over all three.

+1. If your driving via the Glenshee road, Ballater makes even more sense.
Atb