News:

Welcome to the Golf Club Atlas Discussion Group!

Each user is approved by the Golf Club Atlas editorial staff. For any new inquiries, please contact us.


Sean_A

  • Karma: +0/-0
Match VII ended in a three-way tie...so Carnoustie Burnside is added to the mix. Burnside is not a course I would currently place among the top 100 GB&I, but I do have a lot of time for the course and I would have no hesitation recommending others play it.  On to the match

#1. C's opener hasn't changed, short and to the point except for trees compromise the proper strategy of the hole.  BD's opener is an in your face short par 4 played over a quarry then to a huge blind green which slopes hard right.  N&P's also starts with a short par 4 where we get an early view of the dreaded caravan park.  The hole though is quite good.  NO BLOOD.

Beau Desert


#2. C's short 4 comes straight back near the first tee.  The green imaginatively slopes right.  BD's banger par 4 is a reverse dogleg which is overly constricted by trees/rough up the left, but an excellent hole regardess.  N&P is stuck in doldrums with a very dull par 5.  CB's longish par 4 has its green squeezed between OOB and sand....good hole.  However, I think 1 SKIN TO BEAU DESERT



#3. BD's short hole is very clever moving away from the tee, yet the green gives the appearance of being back to front.  C's short par 4 is excellent and these days it will take some control on the part of flat bellies not to run through the green with the drive. N&P's short isn't bad, but nearly of the quality of BD's.  CB's short hole plays over a fronting bunker and is very good.  However, neither it or BD's short are good enough to topple C.  1 SKIN TO CAVENDISH



#4. C's par is a drop-shotter to skinny green, not bad, but no great shakes.  BD's short par 4 is blind from the tee and moves deceptively hard right to a green set below the fairway...awkward hole indeed.  N&P is still groping around for form with a very so-so par 4.  CB's homage to THE South America is by comparison rather bland.  I think by default, BD takes the win based on the very tricky approach. 1 SKIN TO BEAU DESERT

#5. BD's par 4 swinging downhill and left then uphill is excellent.  C's long par 4 is very good as well, but lacking the character of BD's effort.  N&P comes alive with a cool green for its par 4.  CB's 5th is an unusal par 3 over water and hemmed in down the left by trees.  NO BLOOD

Narin & Portnoo


#6. BD's modest par 4 plays straight downhill to a very tricky canted green.  C's par 4 is rather dull despite a very good green. N&P's par 4 plays awkwardly around OOB left then to a pulpit green which is very cool.  CB's short 4 legs right, but the green moves left...another cool hole.  However, I think N&Ps green site alone takes the day here.  1 SKIN TO NARIN & PORTNOO

#7. N&P's knob to knob par 3 requires sharp flight control.  Far less dramatic, but perhaps more fun, BD's redan-like par 3 is comfortably the better design.  C's par 4 isn't really in the conversation.  CB's par 4 drifts left over bumpy ground...another good hole.  I am going to go for design quality over beauty here...1 SKIN TO BEAU DESERT



#8. BD's tight legger left is saved to some degree by a good green.  N&P's short and sharply downhill par 4 is the thing of dreams...a very fine hole.  C's par 4 is very good because of the green, but no match for N&P. Neither is BC's fine long par 4.  1 SKIN TO NARIN & PORNOO



#9. N&P comes right back with another rollicking hole.  Playing over an abrupt crest to a green set well below...this is awesome stuff.  BD's 9th is a great short par 4 which is ever so tempting to have a go at.  The green too is excellent!. C's par 3 is a bit of a dog's dinner visually, but the hole ain't bad.  BC's par three to a pulpit green is excellent, however, I have to go with the raw golf here...1 SKIN TO NARIN & PORTNOO

#10: N&P's par 5 swinging right and diving to a green squeezed by dunes is very good stuff.  BD's 10th is a crafty short hole which produces far more bogies than the card suggests it should.  BC's medium length par 4 turns awkwardly left to a sunken green...yet another lovely hole on an unheralded course.  C's awesome 10th, however, takes the prize....as it has done for several matches now.  1 SKIN TO CAVENDISH



#11. C backs up the 10th with another good hole using the same water, though the drive is a bit obscure for such a dangerous shot. N&P's par 3 to the boundary is very good as well, as is BD's longish par 4 with a severely tilted green.  CB's 11th is good without being exceptional.  This one is too close to call; NO BLOOD.

Cavendish


#12. C's modest par 4 features a killer green running away from play.  N&P is in the doldrums with this hole and the next.  BD's long par 4 double legs between trees, the sort of hole I usually don't care for.  However, I do like that if one can curb the urge to hit driver, its possible to lay-up then play over the trees protecting the second leg. The rare use of green wall trees which I like claims the day.  CB's par 4 is also quite unusual.  The boomerang green can dramatically alter the hole and for this reason it takes the skin....1 SKIN TO CARNOUSTIE BURNSIDE



#13. CB's green is a mini-punchbowl...another good hole.  BD's medium length par 4 plays downhill with the green following suit.  C's par 3 is a marvelous take on the Redan playing much more uphill then the orginal.  N&P....doldrums.  Gotta give this one C...1 SKIN TO CAVENDISH



#14. C's par 5 bending around a wall is a very clever way to make a flat hole interesting.  BD's par 4 is superb.  The approach is very obscured to a difficult and rather large green. N&P's par 5 moving to the left is good, but a bit tight.  CB's long par three to a plateau green saddled in a dune ridge is superb and takes the skin...1 SKIN TO CARNOUSTIE BURNSIDE

 

After 14 holes I have the match:

Beau Desert: 3 skins (2, 4 & 7)

Cavendish: 3 skins (3, 10 & 13)

Narin & Portnoo: 3 skins (6, 8 & 9)

Carnoustie Burnside: 2 skins (12 & 14)

NO BLOOD: 1, 5 & 11

More to follow.

Ciao
« Last Edit: December 31, 2016, 12:04:55 PM by Sean_A »
New plays planned for 2024: Nothing

Sean_A

  • Karma: +0/-0
After 14 holes I have the match:

Beau Desert: 3 skins (2, 4 & 7)

Cavendish: 3 skins (3, 10 & 13)

Narin & Portnoo: 3 skins (6, 8 & 9)

Carnoustie Burnside: 2 skins (12 & 14)

NO BLOOD: 1, 5 & 11

#15. CB's 15th is standard fare par 5.  C's Eden par 3 is a cracker even when many will be hitting wedges.  The slope and angle of the green combined with the front bunker is a masterclass in designing a do or don't die short hole.  N&P's par 5 comes back toward the house along the shore and finishes with a good green.  BD's 15th is a tiger par 5 with one of the most interesting greens in England...due to subsidence.  The drive is cut off by rough ground making it difficult for those with the length to have a go in two.  Laying up leaves a blind second to a fairway which isn't much more wide than the green.  Due to the never-ending interest of the green this hole goes to BD.  1 SKIN TO BEAU DESERT



#16. BD comes roght back with a stellar uphill par 3 over a cross bunker to yet another difficult green.  CB is languishing in the weeds of the mediocrity.  N&P gives us a good par 3, but not to the standard of BD's.  C's par 4 is difficult to like, but the hole is quite good even if a bit chancy due to the severe downhill nature of the approach.  I can't call a winner here because I like C's par 4 and think it deals with the slope quite well. On the hand, BD's par 3 is very well designed.  NO BLOOD.

Beau Desert


#17. BD's longish par 4 is made more difficult by rough ground breaking up the fairway.  The green too is hige with a pronounced right to left slope.  CB's monster par 4 is the sort of hole which only a sadist could design.  The snake-like Barry Burn harangues the golfer on the tee and the approach.  Most will be forced to lay up and try for a wedge putt lay-up.  C's par 3 is good and quite clever.  N&P's par 4 over an elephant's graveyard to a green sloping away from play is simply too original not to proclaim the winner.  1 SKIN TO NARIN & PORTNOO.



#18. N&P's legger right is a good, solid hole.  BD's par 5 plays over not one, but two breaks in the fairway to an absolutely huge green that is very interestng to putt.  CB's home hole is quite straight-away.  C's home hole is an epic of the hilly variety over hilly terrain. Perhaps the best feature is a large dip which will often catch drives and leave an awkward approach.  1 SKIN TO CAVENDISH.

Beau Desert: 4 skins (2, 4, 7 & 15))
Cavendish: 4 skins (3, 10, 13 & 18)
Narin & Portnoo: 4 skins (6, 8, 9 & 17)
Carnoustie Burnside: 2 skins (12 & 14)
NO BLOOD: 1, 5, 11 & 16. 

I have gone and done it again...a three-way tie between Beau Desert, Cavendish and Narin & Portnoo.  I don't seem able to separate these three, but I will give it another go.  Next up

Beau Desert VS Cavendish VS N&P VS Broadstone

Previous Matches

Match VII: Beau Desert V Cavendish V Narin & Portnoo
http://www.golfclubatlas.com/forum/index.php/topic,63838.msg1519815.html#msg1519815

Match VI: Cavendish V Littlestone V Rosapenna OTM
http://www.golfclubatlas.com/forum/index.php/topic,63756.0.html

Match V: Cavendish V Prestbury V Liphook
http://www.golfclubatlas.com/forum/index.php/topic,63743.msg1518020.html#msg1518020

Match IV: Kington V Huntercombe V Cavendish
http://www.golfclubatlas.com/forum/index.php/topic,63725.msg1517854.html#msg1517854

Match III: Kington V New Zealand V Huntercombe
http://www.golfclubatlas.com/forum/index.php/topic,63708.0.html

Match II: Cleeve Cloud V Royal Ashdown Forest V Kington
http://www.golfclubatlas.com/forum/index.php/topic,63674.0.html

Match I: Minch Old V Painswick V Cleeve Cloud
http://www.golfclubatlas.com/forum/index.php/topic,63660.0.html

Ciao
« Last Edit: February 02, 2017, 05:39:46 AM by Sean_A »
New plays planned for 2024: Nothing