I finally played Keney Park the other day for the first time. Wow, was I impressed.
The first hole might just be the best 325-yard hole without a bunker, penalty area, or OB in the world. A tentative iron off the tee could leave a blind approach to a two-tier green where the back half is 3 or 4 feet above the front half--more severe than the first green at Yale. The second is a double-dogleg par 5, with the last two shots steeply uphill. First-time players whose tee shots are too aggressive may find their ball in a creek that's blind from the tee (although a bridge is visible from the tee). These first two holes are better than the opening holes at Hooper in New Hampshire, if you ask me.
Other highlights on the front nine include the par-4 7th, "Biarritz", where the designers didn't even try to compete with the famous version down the road, instead angling the swale from front-left to back-right; and the Reverse Road 9th, with a huge drop-off behind the left side of the green, and a wall of the clubhouse in play just a few paces off the back edge.
The back nine is weaker, although the creek winds through 11 through 17, adding interest. At the short par-4 12th, the drive from an elevated tee must be placed between an attractive/intimidating boundary wall (which separates the course from a cemetery!) and the creek. Okay, actually the creek shouldn't be in play on 12 most days, but into a strong wind, it definitely was.
I look forward to returning to Keney Park again sometime in the next couple of weeks.