[Tony_Muldoon]

I hate to pile in with more cirscuspectual stuff, but...

Fristly I must admitt that I haven't read either biography of Old Tom but...

Is it likely he would have attended a Dinner in a hotel?   Until about 1980 proffesional Golfers wern't even welcome in the Clubhouse.  I can image MacKenzie in his Kilt and Tillinghust in a DJ, but did Old Tom wear anything but tweed?  I am sure he dinned at the table of his friends like Lord Leitrim, but Hotels were the last repositories of snobbery.  The story reads like a lost Chapter from Tommy's Honour.

[Phil Young]

This will be but a brief note. I promised that I would spend a good deal of the day today responding to past posts and answering questions. Unfortunately I will be unable to. I mentioned in my earlier post that I was unavailable on Friday due to a personal matter. This was due to my oldest son undergoing more than 6 hours of complicated oral surgery. Today he is having complications and so I have to help him deal with these.

My apologies and hopefully tomorrow I can get back to the fray...

[Michael Moore]

Game Point Bonnar!

Why are you so gleeful about this?

[Duncan Cheslett]

Game Point Bonnar!

Why are you so gleeful about this?

Because Martin's discovery was a revelation and one that takes us a big step closer to establishing the truth.

I know for a fact that Tommy is not in the least gleeful about some of the game's leading historians having damaged their reputations (irrevocably?) by their unquestioning backing for this story and their scornful dismissal of any suggestion that things may not be as they seem.

That is a spectacle no-one could or should be gleeful about. Neither is the current situation of Ian Scott-Taylor.

Establishing the truth is what matters. That and the well-being of Phil's son.

[Tommy Naccarato]

Thanks Duncan!

Some people just can't get over rejection.....

[Tony_Muldoon]

Game Point Bonnar!

Why are you so gleeful about this?

Because Martin's discovery was a revelation and one that takes us a big step closer to establishing the truth.

I know for a fact that Tommy is not in the least gleeful about some of the game's leading historians having damaged their reputations (irrevocably?) by their unquestioning backing for this story and their scornful dismissal of any suggestion that things may not be as they seem.

That is a spectacle no-one could or should be gleeful about. Neither is the current situation of Ian Scott-Taylor.

Establishing the truth is what matters. That and the well-being of Phil's son.

Duncan which of Phil's posts are "scornful"?  To me it does seem the heat has come from one side in this debate.

[Duncan Cheslett]

Tony,

It wasn't necessarily Phil and it wasn't necessarily on the open forum...

[David_Elvins]

Too obvious a fake for mine.  Most likely this  'controversy' has been constructed deliberately to keep the GCA folk busy whilst Hawtree builds an island green on The Old Course.  

And it's working perfectly.

[DMoriarty]

Phil,  I hope all is well with your son and family.   

When you are able to return to this issue, I’d like to add one crucial question the many above.  This one cuts directly to the heart of your assertions about provenance, possession and control of the Scott-Taylor material.

Isn't it true that you have previously represented that the Scott-Taylor Material was actually stored in a box underneath the bed of Ian Scott-Taylor’s mother?

Thanks.

[Michael Moore]

That is a spectacle no-one could or should be gleeful about.

OK, sorry for interpreting the meticulous parody letter as anything but a celebration of a world in which the Tillinghast minutiae is increasingly error-free.

[Duncan Cheslett]

Post deleted on reflection as inadvisable

[Sean_A]

Yes, it sure seems like folks are enjoying this, despite claims to the opposite.  Otherwise, why all the chatter and "jokes"?  Let Phil respond.  If folks aren't careful, nobody will want to present any historical info on this site.  And who could blame them they way folks carry on?  A mistake is a mistake. Let Phil take as long as he needs to sort stuff out.  What is the hurry anyway?  You lot make bloodhounds seem chilled.

Ciao

[Wayne_Kozun]

Mike,

Here's a list of Tilly courses on which have hosted major and other USGA national championships. It doesn't include those such as Bethpage & Baltusrol where future ones already have been scheduled:

Baltimore CC (5 Farms) – US Women’s Open, US Amateur, PGA Championship
Baltusrol (Lower & Upper) – 5 US Opens, 3 US Women’s Opens, 2 US Amateurs, PGA Championship
Bethpage Black – 2 US Opens
Bethpage Red & Blue - US Public Links
Brook Hollow GC – US Men’s Mid-Amateur
Cedar Crest GC – PGA Championship, US Public Links
Fresh Meadow CC (NLE) – US Open, PGA
Golden Valley CC – US Girls Junior
Hermitage GC – PGA Championship
Indian Hills CC – US Girls Junior
Newport CC – Us Women’s Open, US Women’s Amateur
Oak Hills CC – US Boys Junior
Oaks CC – US Girls Junior
Ridgewood CC – Ryder Cup, US Amateur, US Sr. Open, US Sr. Amateur, Sr. PGA
Rochester G&CC – US Women’s Mid-Am
San Francisco Golf Club – Curtis Cup, US Sr. Amateur
Shawnee CC – PGA, US Women’s Amateur
Somerset Hills CC – Curtis Cup
Swope Memorial – US Women’s Public Links
Tulsa CC – US Women’s Amateur
Winged Foot GC (Eats & West) – 5 US Opens, 2 US Women’s Opens, US Sr. Open, 2 US Amateurs, PGA

It may not be a major but Scarboro Golf & Country Club (redesigned by Tilly circa 1925) in Toronto has hosted four Canadian Opens (40,47,53,63) won by Sam Snead, Bobby Locke, Dave Douglas and Doug Ford and the 1958 Canadian Am.

FYI - Stanley Thompson was designing Cedar Brook (later Cedar Brae) Golf Club across the street around the same time so it is possible that he met Stanley Thompson at this time.

But this thread seems to have gotten a bit beyond this issue. 

[Jim Franklin]

Not sure if this was added but Baltimore CC also hosted a Walker Cup and the Senior's Players Championship.

[DMoriarty]

Bump

[David Harshbarger]

Wow!


Take a break from GolfClubAtlas.com and who knows what you'll.  Looks like one heck of a kerfuffle, dustup, donnybrook damn! it's hard to write like it's 1901!

[John_Conley]

it's hard to write like it's 1901!

Nobody would ever need to.

[Tags:]

Tags:

[Tags:]

Tags:

Call to undefined function theme_linktree()