Another tough choice for the outsider, and so he must again rely on that most unquantifiable of measuring sticks, i.e. the subjectivity of personal taste and preference. Good on White for starting the back 9 with such a striking and interesting Par 3 -- but I guess I like my architects with slightly less humour (the idea I think is to give the putter a roller-coaster ride, not an actual roller coaster); and as well, somewhat like the 12th at Augusta, the problem/test isn't going left or right but long or short, since the greens are wide but narrow; and downhill and exposed like that I don't trust my 8 iron re distance control. The Red's Par 5 meanwhile 'sets up' beautifully, the vista from the tee and its relationship to the design seems spot on, and (from other sources I looked at) the design/topography and green site keeps things interesting even for me (who usually just sees an meh/blah 2nd shot lay up on most Par 5s). So, I give this one to Red.
As we come fully into the back nine, and after 10 holes, PJP's scorecard (again, the only one that matters) now has it All Square!