Ah, this is what it's all about, on a couple of fronts. Design-wise, I've been waiting for the freedom-naturalism of Red #4, a Ballyneal-St Andrews mix of almost daunting choice, with few visual directives. Personal-taste wise, the White is hurt here by my preternatural disinterest in most Par 5s, especially those built on relatively flat land (btw, I have viewed photos/descriptions from other sources); for my tastes, you just can't DO much with that, either architecturally or in the playing. (You'll note that my view of the Red's early Par 5 was similarly affected by little more than my personal preferences in this regard). Our Tommy designs one like he does best, while the veteran produces another in a terrific series of fine holes, but this time is hamstrung by 'the form'. This one goes to the Red.
So, after 4 holes, PJP scores the match - All square.