After spending an incredibly beautiful weekend with the best hosts imaginable on FINY, I have to mention a hole that no one seems to bring up on these forums.
The Island's other course, The Hay Harbor Club, does get worthy praise on this site but usually the details go little beyond describing #2, an ocean-front tough uphill par 4. As exquisite as the hole is, the adjacent downhill hole to it's left is just as stunning. After climbing up to a skyline green on #5 (the best kind since there's little in the way of distance markers on the whole course) you are brought to the 6th tee. It's a medium length par 3 looking down over the most of the course. It's a long way down and the green is just begging you to drop your ball in like a lawn dart, but not so fast. The ocean is crashing to your left and the wind is really going to have fun with your shot. It wasn't a terribly windy day but my ball seemed to just be tossed around in the sky. I really could have spent the rest of my day standing on that ledge and just firing away. I think the goal was to aim short and low and let it roll on but the landing zone seemed smaller than the green. Awesome, awesome hole.
I'm not crazy right?