After enjoying a splendid Walker Cup I had the good fortune to play Piping Rock. This is another great expression of the Macdonald/Raynor approach to laying a golf course on the land with their stamp very evident. There are many fine holes; no poor ones and a pleasant variety of features and terrain and a wonderful flowing routing.
Great Redan, Knole, and Road holes to name a few and a routing that allows one to see at one point 13 holes from a single vantage point!
The practice range is marvelous as it is situated adjacent to the clubhouse and first tee and affords a view of THE ENTIRE OUTWARD LOOP! What a way to commence a round.
It is with disappointment that I read the GCA course review as it may be one of the briefest in the portfolio.
So Ran I respectfully request that you make it a point to revisit Piping Rock and post one of your marvelous review/pictorials that is worthy of this old gem