Used them all. The latest hot trend is the Better Billy Bunker, which my clients seem most favorably impressed with, if they can get past the cost. Second fave is Bunker Solutions, another expensive option calling for a white astroturf type material as liner. It's much more durable than the standard fabrics, or appears to be. All the other fabric liners are cheaper options, but believed not to last as long, so the lifetime cost may be similar.
That is the real problem with any liner method, no one really has even ten years of data on any of them, other than the early fabrics, which didn't hold up, and have been improved.