Bill, Bill, and Pat.
You have your perspectives and I have experience on both sides.
There's a difference between the public and private scenarios. But between Pebble and CPC it is not so much. The caddies are independent contractors, so do have some leverage against doing every thing the Company/Club tells them to do. And because they're independent, each one is different. Each may have different reasons for wanting to swap out your bag. One might even pick yours up and agree to carry it. It's become an SOP and they've been doing it for awhile now, everyday. BTW, The Company facilitates the purchase of those bags. Why? So, their corp of caddies comeback everyday. And why does the caddie buy them? As an investment. Those bags are gonna pay for his mortgage. But, Seriously, and with all due respect, do people walk into your office and tell you how to do your job?
I use to carry the old heavy leather bag when I was a kid too. It doesn't come close to doing the job EVERYDAY, on those courses. Some of those "Lazy" caddies get around multiple times a day, too. Mostly they go again because they're needed, not because they're greedy.
The dive weight reference was to illustrate how important controlling, ahead of time, what a professional caddie carries.
What's wrong with my maximizing my partners connivence?
Adam. let's not kid anyone. I accept that you once caddied, so you know full well the mentality in all caddie yards: 100% professionalism while looping on the course, and a half-kidding, half- disdainful/smirking/juvenille/smartass attitude about the players when not working. Members know it exists and it is no big deal. But when it comes to changing out one lightweight carry bag for another, the caddy is just jerking around and the caddy master should not allow it. Don't think for a minute that caddies are not just seeing what they can get away with... all us boys do it all the time... Caddies at CPC and Pebble get away with this nonsense that caddies at NGLA, Merion and about a thousand other clubs would not DREAM of doing. Are you telling me that there is an endemic bad back problems in CA? I'll call it California soft.
Bill, Just so we don't have a misunderstanding, I 'm not familiar with all caddie yards. Just the Pebble Beach co. I never really hung out on the bench very much, so I'm not privy,nor did hear caddies talking about what douche their last loop was. I took people on their face and adapted accordingly. FYI, The caddiemaster does work for the company, and there were damn few who knew how to be a good one. You may think it's just some easy remedial job, but, to be a good caddiemaster requires a wide range of people skills and the awareness to use them optimally.
Also, All carry bags are not created equally. They don't all function the same. Having issues out on the course, with your bag, be it strap or leg related, is designed out of the equation by swapping it out. Get over it and focus on your round.
Once, I was paired with a brand new Louis Vitton leather gold trim bag whose owner refused to allow a swap. He took a cart. Sure I coulda carry his bag, but I would've needed a week off, and thats exactly what I told him.
Funny you mention Merion. Big deal, the guy carried my own bag. He left it near 18 fairway so he wouldn't have to carry it down and up the quarry for 17 and 18. As a result, I wasn't able to finish the 17th hole because my bag wasn't there and he didn't bring an extra ball or the right club. Point being, at Pebble, nobody leaves a bag for convenience. Your clubs and belongings are always there by your side.
I feel bad for those who view the caddie/player relationship as master and slave. It says more about them, then the caddie.