I normally try to stay out of these caddie battles,and am a fan of the UK/Irish model of choice of trolley, carry, or caddie.
I'm not a fan of carts as an alternative to caddies (and I would give the cart away for free to a medically disabled or age appropriate rider, on the condition that they either take or look after the caddie in their group)
I must say while I understand some of the points Peper was so awkwardly trying to make, that I found much of the article, and certainly the tone, quite offensive.
Not sure where Peper thinks these schoolkid caddies are going to come from weekdays in April, May September, or October.
The fact is at a small amount of certain clubs, caddies are desired and expected. Caddies have to be provided for those that want them when the kids are unavailable.
Of course we all like to support Evans Scholarship programs and the like, but denying the need for post school age caddies is completely unrealistic, and to hold it against the more mature caddy who's trying to pay his bills like anyone else is well, just wrong. They are an integral part of any caddie program through a majority of the season and can't just go away because school's out and you want a 15 year old bag carrier. I'd say he simply hasn't thought about it, but it certainly comes off smug.
Many posters bring up legitimate issues regarding caddies, and as I stated I'm not a fan of them being mandatory, but I understand why many places(including us, but I'm working on it) have the mandatory policy to keep caddies around.
Even though it's difficult, it seems that if caddies weren't mandatory, and carts were not allowed as a substitute, that the golf staff could soon enough determine what the actual demand is, and offer the appropriate amount of caddies accordingly.
It's something I wrestle with daily, but our members aren't sensitive to the cumulative caddie fees of a season, and we get almost no requests to NOT take a caddie . My guess is there are some places where it becomes a real potential member eliminating issue.
Comparing caddies to a rest room attendant is unduly harsh
, it's amazing a former caddie (or anyone of any decency) would use that analogy.
It's great that George got to go to Scotland, and his frugality
was further enhanced while he was there.
Meanwhile there are plenty of players who request and demand the use of caddies, and those caddies have to make a living, and last I checked, a caddie can't pay his rent in The Hamptons (or anywhere else) on $38/day. (and that assumes they get out every day, which they don't) Do you think George knows what minimum wage is? throw in the obligatory hour on the range and lunch at the turn(to say nothing of caddieshack waiting time), and they are well below that at $38. George may zip around in his cart in 3 hours, but that's not what's happening at a destination high end course with a fourball with knee high fescue, particularly when the course is not crowded and guests are enjoying their relaxed day in a leisurely manner.
Ironically, I share many of Brent and Mike Sweeney's opinions on this subject, but I still find this article offensive and poorly thought out.
Not sure that matters though, as I'm pretty sure GP has a similar opinion of golf pros.