Alex,
So are you having a routing contest or a real Armchair Architect Contest? In past contests folks did a routing with all the features and even score cards and narrative description of holes... there will be a natural attrition as reality strikes.. and you're thinking about one page reviews of just routing???
Please clarify..
...Yes.
This will be a real Armchair Architect Contest with descriptions and yardages, BUT in order for any round of voting to take place that narrows this field down to a sizable number for the judges we need to have a limit on viewable material.
If the whole point of having a round of voting to narrow things down to a group of finalists is to make sure that the judges don't have too much material to go through, then there must be a limit to the material your average schmo is going to have to go through in the preliminary voting.
Hope that clears it up. I can't think of another way it would work at this point, but once the finalists are determined I think we can post detailed entries of those who did not make the cut.
My limit that I suggested is 1 page, but that page can have as detailed a routing as you like (you'll likely want it to be your routing).