After seeing the Mackenzie thread, I thought it would be neat to determine the best template holes if we were to make an eclectic 18.
I know there have been 'rank the best redan' etc. threads in the past, but to my knowledge never a full 18 holes.
I think we should leave NGLA out, as it would take home too much glory, and focus on the rest of their portfolio.
My nominations:
Redan - Piping Rock
Eden - Essex County CC
Short - Shoreacres
Biarritz - Yale
Alps - Fisher's Island
Road - Shoreacres
Punchbowl - Creek
Bottle - Essex County CC (west course, now Francis Byrne)
Double Plateau - Fisher's Island
Maiden - Essex County CC (very unique green, also the Road Hole)
Raynor's Prize Dog Leg -
Leven -
Cape - Mid Ocean Club