Sorry to see negative feedback on any Strantz courses, but it isn't uncommon. But Caledonia would typically be one of the least controversial courses he did. It is just a magnificent course in a magnificent setting, and deserving of every Top 100 list on which it appears.
True Blue just across the street is much more likely to get negative reactions, though IMO if you pick the correct tees (3rd set instead of the second for most single digits) it is just a wonderful golf course. I have written here many times that to see Caledonia and True Blue, which could not be more different from one another, almost on adjoining property and realize that the same man designed both gives an appreciation of GCA and artistry that few other 36 hole days can match.
It isn't near the coast, of course, but Tot Hill is likely the worst piece of land Strantz worked on. That said, I think Tot Hill is far, far above average and classic Strantz in that he makes it look far, far more difficult than it plays. I've played Tot Hill three or four times and would jump at the chance to go again, as I would with any of his courses.