I have had a few questions about this.
Specifically Jim asked "I wonder which templates Raynor would have laid out and where. " which we talked about many times as we played Fishers Island.
Here are a few of my ideas, though it would be great to hear from Tom Doak, Geoff Shackelford, George Bahto, etc
ASSUMING the (never seen before) Raynor routing was similar, which holes lend themselves well to a MacRaynor.
#2 would be a great Cape hole off the tee
#3 would be a fantastic Eden
#7 A magnificent reverse Redan
#8 Alps (can you have an Alps on the tee shot?)
#10 Road
#13 Double Plateau
#15 Short
Can you imagine a Short with the proper bunkering, thumbprint green, and howling 20 mph wind!
#16 225 yard Biarritz