I'll bite, Mr. Lyon
Prohibitively authoritative list, as always. I must have played, so if there's a glaring omission in your opinion, I've probably not played the course or I feel emotionally attached to my selection.
1) Inniscrone, Mountain Lake, West Shore Country Club near Harrisburg, PA
2) Five Ponds Golf Club in Warminster, PA (My first GIR and a decent hole to boot), Lancaster Country Club
3) Huntingdon Valley
4) Lederach, Tot Hill Farm, Rolling Green, Bethpage Black
5) Palmetto Golf Club, Merion West, Tobacco Road
6) Inniscrone
7) Palmetto Golf Club
Huntingdon Valley, Lancaster, Rolling Green (All Flynn, hmmm)
9) Rolling Green
10) Cobb's Creek
11) Jeffersonville, Macullough's Emerald Links, Inniscrone
12) Lederach, Huntingdon Valley, Mountain Lake
13)
14)
15) Cobb's Creek
16) Whitemarsh Valley
17)
18) Huntingdon Valley, Glen Ridge
I'll have to think about the omissions for awhile. Tom Doak is correct, this is a difficult list to actually consider good choices. I tried to avoid holes where a cross slope is more influential on the hole strategy than the uphill (i.e. the 15th at Huntingdon Valley). This choice lead to an influx or holes where the upslope is generally traversed in one shot (like the 11th at Jeffersonville and Macullough's or one-shotters like the 3rd at Huntingdon Valley, the 8th at Lancaster or the 11th at Inniscrone) or where the uphill terrain simply dominates the hole (18th at Huntingdon Valley or 6th at Inniscrone).
Only two holes longer 500 yards is on the list at present (4th at Bethpage Black, and the long 9th at Rolling Green). Do holes generally reached in three shots make for good uphill candidates?