News:

Welcome to the Golf Club Atlas Discussion Group!

Each user is approved by the Golf Club Atlas editorial staff. For any new inquiries, please contact us.


Lester George

Kalen,

I did not take it personally. 

I just think you ought to see it before you declare it "a sad day in Gca.com history" when our restoration is far closer to what Macdonald and Raynor built than any "faithful links-style tribute" you have seen.  Stating it that way, I only concluded that you should then see the Old White before making your declaration.  No offense was meant or taken.

What we put back was religously close to the original.  I took quite a gamble putting the dragons teeth back because I knew it would be looked on as eye candy.  But when you are hired to "restore" and the owner (at the time) was convinced (by me and others) that a leap back to their roots was far greater than a modern renovation, you pretty much have to weigh the practical with the quirk.  At the time, if I had walked away from the dragons teeth as not practical, it would have opened a pandoras box of problems justifying other quirks that we needed to debate.

Lester

Mac Plumart

 :'( :-\ ??? :o ??? :-\ :'(


 :)
Sportsman/Adventure loving golfer.

Mac Plumart

Okay...enough of my "funnin'" with Scott Warren.

I think Old White might end up winning this thing.  The Dragon's Teeth add a lot of coolness to the look of the hole and the angle of that green is awesome.  Bottom line...great work here and I feel that this thing has momentum to win the tourney.  Add in the faithfulness of the restoration work and you just might have an irresitable force at Old White.

Sportsman/Adventure loving golfer.

Terry Lavin


What we put back was religously close to the original.  I took quite a gamble putting the dragons teeth back because I knew it would be looked on as eye candy.  But when you are hired to "restore" and the owner (at the time) was convinced (by me and others) that a leap back to their roots was far greater than a modern renovation, you pretty much have to weigh the practical with the quirk.  At the time, if I had walked away from the dragons teeth as not practical, it would have opened a pandoras box of problems justifying other quirks that we needed to debate.

Lester

Bravo.  That decision took some nerve, but it also shows an artist's heart, which is just great.
Nobody ever went broke underestimating the intelligence of the American people.  H.L. Mencken

Lester George


Nice words Terry, thank you.

Lester

Greg Clark

Old White for me.  I liked the Redan on Pacific Dunes quite a bit more than the Redan on Old Mac.

Tags: