This discussion group is best enjoyed using Google Chrome, Firefox or Safari.
Are we voting which hole is better, or which hole is a better Alps? Clearly Yale is a more faithful Alps rendition; the second is blind no matter where you place your tee shot and you mustn't come up short with your second or you'll be bunkered. That bunker is fairly shalllow and even I got up and down to a right pin easily from there. I think St Enodoc has more tee shot interest, placement is critical both for distance and direction. The second shot is intimidating and thrilling, even with a 9 iron in hand. Both are great holes.I vote for St Enodoc.