Matt,
Would love to know your Top-10 muni plays for NY/NJ/CT and maybe a top 25 nationally if you have one.
There is Mercer Oaks in West Windsor, NJ (near princeton and the Peddie School course in Hightstown). There is an East and West course, of which I have only played the older one. Better than average golf here. I would put this 36 hole facility (good chipping and putting area and grass driving range) ahead of most NY munis I have seen. Good faciltity, less crowded, and good golf for the price.
My archive of munis is limited but here it goes NY/NJ/CT:
Bethpage Black, Bethpage, Long Island
Mercer Oaks, West Windsor, NJ
LaTourette, Staten Island, NY
Richter Park, Danbury, CT
Mohansic, Yorktown Heights, NY
For maximum enjoyment, try to get off at LaTourette as early as possible and not on a w/e.