Brian--
Caledonia's my favorite Grand Strand course. It excels all the others, in my opinion, in that it would be a really neat course to walk, is unimpeded by housing, and (most importantly) Strantz displayed such a deft touch and created a bunch of golf holes that are quite different (and, a lot of people think, better) than those on other golf courses. My ten round split between Caledonia and the Dye Club would be 6-4 in Caledonia's favor.
Brett--
Like Paul, I'm curious to hear your thoughts on the course. I can certainly see the Dye "look" rubbing people the wrong way. I personally really like the Dye aesthetic in general so I find his Barefoot course to be quite enjoyable.
~ ~ ~
Now, the back nine:
#10: 344/317/287/256--I think they've abandoned the 344 tee actually, but the hole is great from the 317 tee anyway. It's a lot like the 10th hole at Whistling Straits, I gather, in that you can drive it up by or onto the green if you want or lay back for a solid wedge shot and have the hole play about the same general difficulty, meaning that a player can play to his/her strengths, which I love in a short/semi-drivable par 4.
#11: 461/402/366/291--The third of the long par 4s, this hole offers a bit of a different look. A little more restrained-looking than some holes, but the green complex, which is saddle-like, was one of my favorites on the course. Apologies for forgetting a shot from the tee; it's a slight dogleg right where you can do the angles thing again a little bit.
#12: 538/494/452/403--The penultimate par 5 is very lunar-looking, with a very hittable half-pipe of a fairway. The rub is that the second shot (on which you may well wish to go for it in two) is pretty blind. Another really good green site, especially for a par 5.
#13: 392/354/332/292--Probably the easiest par 4 on the course and also the least visually "built-up" hole. Of course I three-putted from 15 feet when I played it. Another green surrounded by mounds rather than hazards. A good respite before the closing stretch.
#14: 475/429/367/309--Another brute of a par 4. This time, the hole angles left, so you can make the hole shorter by putting your ball at risk of a sandy fate to that side. There's also an interesting greenside feature that is, well, featured in one pic.
#15: 226/204/162/119--Great hanging par 3 that seems similar in concept to some of the ones at Whistling Straits. The green is very deep and so the hole can play radically differently on different days. Go for the gusto or bail out a bit right. Options!
#16: 574/526/494/400--The last par 5 is a good one with another interesting green site. I forgot tee and landing area pics; my bad.
#17: 188/175/158/105--Very inventive par 3. Long, skinny angled green on a pad that is completely surrounded and elevated by railroad ties and sort of sits above a wetland area. Different; cool.
#18: 471/415/368/276--The finisher is what you'd expect from a lot of Dye courses: long par 4 hard by a body of water. Just because it's been done a lot doesn't make it bad and I like this hole as a final battle.
Hope you enjoyed the tour. I like the course but would love to hear the dissenters' rationales.
Cheers.
--Tim