Ran,
I understand that Forse's work is post Amateur, and that the club did a smart thing regarding his work. Rather than present the membership with a Master Plan that could draw resistance to change, even though change might have been restoration, they decided to adopt Ron's recommendations at the Green committee level, implementing the plan over a few years.
I understand that resistance to a fairway irrigation system is fairly universal, and that supporters of such don't remain on the committees or board very long.
I had heard that Tillie was inspired following dinner one night at Baron von Rachel's, but my sources are in Florida for the winter and I can't confirm same until they return. Incidentally, Newport won't open up for about a month, when the Season arrives.
Ran, as neat as this hole is, the previous hole is almost as spectacular, playing into a brisk head or crossing wind.
The 6th hole is neat as well, with some unique features, and playing into a brisk wind.
I think this is one of the most underrated courses in the country. It is also a course you can play 36 holes a day on, for the entire summer, and never get bored.
We will play Newport, Point Judith where Ron Prichard did a wonderful restoration, Wannamoisett, and Metacomet this summer, I hope.
Descendents of Baron Von Rachel still reside in the Newport and Providence area, perhaps we can interview them for GCA.
Regarding Maidstone, they are similar, but there have been times when I've been disappointed in Maidstone's shaggy condition, although I understand that look and maintainance practices are things of the past.