News:

Welcome to the Golf Club Atlas Discussion Group!

Each user is approved by the Golf Club Atlas editorial staff. For any new inquiries, please contact us.


Scott Warren

  • Karma: +0/-0
I spent three days earlier this week checking out Casa Serena in the Czech Republic, about 70km south east of Prague.

It was designed in by GCA's own Robin Hiseman (European Golf Design - www.egd.com) for the owner of consumer electronics manufacturer Foxconn. It's entirely private at present, aside from hosting one of the most lucrative events on the European Senior Tour each September since 2008 (when it opened), but there are thoughts of opening the course, and the adjoining 17th Century Chateau Roztez, to the occasional corporate booking.

The course is remarkably bold in its contouring and hazards, befitting a site with the strong changes of elevation, wide corridors and expansive vistas.

The width of the playing areas meant beautiful long undulations could be fashioned, with fescue rough separating many of the holes. The landforms in many cases extend across a number of holes, tying them together and giving the feeling of cohesion as you move through the round.

The bunkering is particularly bold: large and strategically placed, with many shaped with a number of bays. There's also good use of bunkers on horizon points to foreshorten the visuals, playing havoc with distance perception (there are no sprinkler head yardages, just 100/150/200m markers to the front of greens).

A lot of it is artfully done, but most fit a general strategy that makes for lots of fun heroic drives for the better golfer but wide, welcoming bail-out areas for the rest. There's lots on diagonals at play off the tee, creating a gradually sterner test.

The greens aren't as wild as some other new courses, in large part due to the client's desire for them to be able to get up to speeds of 11.5 and 12 on the stimpmeter. But they contain plenty of interest in the form of long shaping that is more subtle to the eye and takes some reading. The green shapes also make for some wonderfully wicked pin positions that you'll see in the pics to follow: front left on 1, front right on 5, back left on 11, front right on 16 and just above the false front on 17.

There are 1001 lessons to be learned and honed on repeat plays, which suits a course that will largely be played repeatedly by a small group of people.

I have to give a particular shout-out to the par fives: 6, 14 and 18. Having played his new holes at Dornoch on the Struie (10, which unfortunately has lost many of its bunkers, and 13), and now these three, Robin seems to have a particular talent for creating interest over a 470y+ hole, whether it's being played in two shots or three. I only hope my pics can do those holes justice.

ALL DISTANCES IN METRES - because they are sensible on the Continent and, to borrow from Vincent Vega in Pulp fFction, "they got the metric system over there" - add 10% for yards.

Also, the pics are a combo of those I took this week and some from last summer, showing the course in a few different conditions.


1st - par 4 - 316/309/281
The opening hole sweeps left, offering a wide fairway for the first swing of the day, but a diagonal string of bunkers cut down the left offering some risk and reward for anyone willing to get into it from the word go.

There is generally good benefit to be gained by chancing the sand, unless the pin is hard left, in which case playing to the right-hand-side and as close to the green as possible seems wise. As with many holes, it pays to consider the pin position before you pull a club from your bag on the tee.

As we came to the green one one of our walks around the course, a Czech greenkeeper drove by, greeted Robin warmly and proudly told him "zis eez my favourite hole". Robin asked why. "I play it one day and hit good drive, then seven iron, I pitch to zis pin, very difficult pin, and make an eagle!".

One thing that stood out among the greenkeepers (lead by two Englishman - Stu and Sam) is just how passionate they seemed about the course. The conditioning is amazing. The area had received seven weeks of constant heavy rain prior to last week but I wouldn't have had more than three or four squealchy steps the whole time I was there - a testament to their work and to the drainage (casa Serena is built on clay).

The drive:


Approach from the left:


Approach from very close to the green, 270m or so from the tee:


2nd - par 3 - 202/187/141m

While 143m is the shortest men's tee, it's the one used in the Casa Serena Open and the one we played from. The green, one of the most severe on the course with fall-aways to three sides suits a mid-iron approach.

The bunker short doesn't really come into play - at least it shouldn't - but it catches your eye and asserts itself visually. It's a theme also cleverly used at 4, 8 and 12.

The thin dark line above the large bunker is a small greenside bunker around the back of which the green wraps.

« Last Edit: June 14, 2010, 04:15:47 AM by Scott Warren »

Scott Warren

  • Karma: +0/-0
3rd - par 4 - 402/384/353

Climbing steeply up the hill, the 3rd calls for a bold tee shot that either skirts or carries the bunker on the RHS. There is a flattish landing spot short left, but anything long enough to clear the bunker but played timidly to the left will run into an uneven lie.

From level with the bunker is about a 7i or 8i to the green, over a great centreline bunker and a narrow finger of rough short of the green that forces the golfer laying up to position his ball with purpose.



Scott Warren

  • Karma: +0/-0
4th - par 4 - 440/413/396

This is where the excitement really kicks in.

Another heroic option on the drive, with huge benefit for carrying the LHS bunker, a carry of 230m or so from the back tee (205/190m further forward), or hugging it with a draw.

The land on the RHS of the fairway slopes right, taking the tee shot down to a slot that brings the bunkers around the green very much into play on the approach.

A well-executed drive that lands in the left half will kick hard down some amazingly bold undulations, earning the A1 like into the angled green, with about 50m of fairway hidden from view between the wide bunker short of the green and the green itself. From the better angles that is much more evident.

Despite the length of the hole, the slope makes it play very short if executed well. I usually only drive the ball 230m or so, and I had 120m for my second on the back of a well-placed tee shot.





Ben Stephens

  • Karma: +0/-0
Scott,

Great photos! look forward to the rest - seen the layout on Google Earth recently but your photos expresses the course a lot more with slopes and undulations etc.

Boony and I are playing against Robin and his brother Andy at Rutland Water this weekend.  We will definitely ask Robin questions about this course and his exciting new venture in Madrid

Cheers
Ben

Scott Warren

  • Karma: +0/-0
5th - par 4 - 301/279m

Uphill and angling to the right, the best line is gained by flying a centreline bunker, setting up a pitch to the elevated green, or by playing safely to the left with an iron and then a wedge in. There is an avenue down the right allowing a direct crack at the large double green, but disappointingly it's maintained as rough - a couple of inches long - removing the temptation to try your luck.

Depending on the pin, a smashed tee shot at the left edge of the green can pay dividends, as it's a pretty easy chip to most parts of the green from there.

Drive:


A little way up the fairway from the tee:


From 70 yards out:

Scott Warren

  • Karma: +0/-0
6th - par 5 - 520/479m

The first of the three shotters.

Driving over the LHS fairway bunker will see your ball land on a kickpad throwing it well forward, though a drive down the middle will also get some benefit from the natural rolls of the land.

The second shot brings a number of options into play, depending on the pin position.

Over the nest of bunkers to the right is a large area of fairway, with a narrow avenue over the bunker short left that will help to feed the ball to the green if you're in range.

Between the two and closer to the green are some centreline bunkers sitting about 25 yards short of the green that must considered if you decide to take dead aim at the flag.

The immanse undulation hides the generousity of the landing areas from view, while the green has two or three separate areas broken up by ridges.

Drive:


Second shot in prime season:


A bit closer:


Short of the centreline bunkers near the green:


From the right, having taken on the massive bunkers on the right of the second and third pics:


NB: The excess rough around the bunkers is a result of the massive recent rainfall making it difficult and dangerous to mow tight in those areas. As you'll see from the pics that aren't mine, the ones with the burnt off fescue, that isn't the normal maintenance practise.

Scott Warren

  • Karma: +0/-0
7th - par 4 - 340/313/300

A straight two-shotter that plays tougher than its length suggests.

The undulations increase the closer you get to the green on the left hand side, which is the line you need to take to hit the green. As such, a pitch from 40 yards or so is likely to be quite blind, while playing safely to the right opff the tee with an iron will leave a wedge over a short right greenside bunker and with another deep trap waiting behind the green.

The drive:


Approach from the right:


Approach from the left:

Scott Warren

  • Karma: +0/-0
8th - par 4 - 425/409/383

One of my favourite holes on the course. The drive tempts you to go as far left as you can, with a gruadually longer carry and your reward for the risk is an approach straight downhill to the green without the short right bunker playing on your mind or the LHS greenside downslope threatening to channel your ball away. Looks great, plays great.



The tree in the RHS foreground is the tall tree visible in the tee shot picture over the middle of the bunker between the two middle bays.

« Last Edit: June 12, 2010, 10:13:37 AM by Scott Warren »

Scott Warren

  • Karma: +0/-0
9th - par 3 - 187/169/142m

This hole has some Redan qualities: the green offset, approach and green angle, bunkering... a fun hole.




Jeff Doerr

  • Karma: +0/-0
Thanks for the tour so far - looking forward to the back nine.
"And so," (concluded the Oldest Member), "you see that golf can be of
the greatest practical assistance to a man in Life's struggle.”

Buck Wolter

  • Karma: +0/-0
This part of the world has come a long way. I lived in Slovakia back in 1994 and while in Prague hit balls at what I think was the only course in the Czech Republic. I borrowed a club and was hitting balls when the pensioner working behind the counter puts on a hockey helmet and grabs a shag bag and walks out in front of 10 people hitting balls to start picking.

The photos look great -- typically it seems that a continental Europe golf course has something about it that makes it easy to guess where it is but this could be anywhere (I mean that in a good way).  My guess is the difference is a billionaire owner with a large piece of property suited to golf.

I wonder if Terry Guo will be doing more of this globally --Foxconn is big in Vietnam as well.
Those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end, for they do so with the approval of their own conscience -- CS Lewis

John Mayhugh

  • Karma: +0/-0
Scott,
The course photographs well.  I really like the use of the land so far.

On the third hole, how long is the carry over the bunkers on the right part of the fairway?  I like the look of that tee shot a lot.

Scott Warren

  • Karma: +0/-0
It does set up well. That's one of the things about the course, it's full of tee shots you just want wait to have a crack at.

Carrying the 3rd fairway bunker is 185m from the middle men's tee and 230m from the tips.

Scott Warren

  • Karma: +0/-0
10th - par 4 - 374/356m




11th - par 4 - 345/336/307m
Temptation is to fly the bunkers for a good look at the green, with a really bad angle from the safe left hand side, particularly to a back left pin.





12th - par 4 - 390/368/339m
Another chance to take a risk on the drive for a great angle and shorter distance into the plateau green. It was standing on what would become this tee that Robin says he got a feel for what could be created on this land.







13th - par 3 - 184/169/154m



14th - par 5 - 525/497/455m
Great bunker in a rise about 50m short left of the green, with anything hit straight to the green from distance likely to be fed right into the short right bunker.




15th - par 4 - 372/363/333m
The drive looks crazy tight, but a very wide fairways is hiding past the fescue, with some great undulation in the fairway.





16th - par 4 - 391/381/353m
Really eye-catching drive over the saddle, then a second where the ground short hides much of the front of the green, and a shaved slope on the right lurks to sweep away anything played with the lean of the hill. The only bunkerless hole on the course.



17th - par 3 - 170/149/141m
The green is extremely steep back-to-front, and the slope short of the green is like a ski slope. Not one you want to get above the pin on when the greens are at 11+.



18th - par 5 - 502/475/467m
The cross bunker on the second shot makes the hole. You need to drive hard left on the bunkers to get the best angle past it, then if you bail left on the second the third will be largely blind and aimed at a massive, deep bunker right of the green. If you take on the challenge of going straight over the cross bunker, the land will help you find the green, or at worst have a straightforward third.



« Last Edit: June 13, 2010, 03:54:42 PM by Scott Warren »

Adam Lawrence

  • Karma: +0/-0
I was really, really impressed with Casa Serena. The shaping is epic: the scale of the rolls, humps and hollows on some of the holes - the fourth, the sixth, the fourteenth, fifteenth and sixteenth are really good examples - is just immense. Yet it doesn't look out of place, because the contouring is carried through the width of the fields.

My only real issue is aesthetic - the scale of the contouring makes the bunkers seem a little bit understated. But since Robin was working with a construction crew that didn't have any experience of shaping on this kind of scale, that's understandable. And maybe the greens are a little understated also, but given he knew the client wanted to be able to get them up to very high speeds, it was probably a sensible decision.

It's the second of his courses I've visited, after the Riffa Views course in Bahrain, which contains one of the bravest greens I have ever seen, the first, which is around sixty metres long and falls almost two metres from front two back, so I don't think Robin fears severe greens. In both cases, though, I have been really, really impressed by the attention to detail and the sheer playability of the golf course. Assuming he gets to build it, I'm really looking forward to seeing the course he is designing in Madrid for the Spanish 2018 Ryder Cup bid.
Adam Lawrence

Editor, Golf Course Architecture
www.golfcoursearchitecture.net

Principal, Oxford Golf Consulting
www.oxfordgolfconsulting.com

Author, 'More Enduring Than Brass: a biography of Harry Colt' (forthcoming).

Short words are best, and the old words, when short, are the best of all.

John Mayhugh

  • Karma: +0/-0
Scott,
The rest of the course looks great.

No report on the beer selection in the clubhouse? As long as you're rubbing it in. 

Scott Warren

  • Karma: +0/-0
All good points, Adam.

John: Alright then... Free pints of Pilsner Urquell being handed out by not unfortunate looking Czech girls (does that country have any ugly women aged under 40?!).

Robin_Hiseman

  • Karma: +0/-0

Scott is too modest to mention that he won the tournament being held that day for the assembled media, who were there to promote the forthcoming European Senior Tour event.  Scott was the only person to play to their handicap all day, totting up 36 stableford points.  I hope to see him wearing the bright red 'Casa Serena Open' rainjacket with pride someday soon!

My only real issue is aesthetic - the scale of the contouring makes the bunkers seem a little bit understated. But since Robin was working with a construction crew that didn't have any experience of shaping on this kind of scale, that's understandable. And maybe the greens are a little understated also, but given he knew the client wanted to be able to get them up to very high speeds, it was probably a sensible decision.


As ever, Adam makes very fair and well considered comments.  I had a real desire to give the bunkers a more naturalised look, but when it came to marking them out I just could not convince myself that it was the right thing to do here.  Given the purpose of the course as a private retreat, I just didn't feel that 84 frenzied looking bunkers was conducive to the relaxation and enjoyment the course was intended to promote.  I believe I made the right decision.

The greens contouring was a similar case study.  They were my first pure bent greens, having previously done all fescue/bent greens in the UK and Northern Europe.  It was always intended that they would run fast and I really had to throttle back my natural instincts to throw the surfaces about a bit.  All through construction and grow in I was telling myself off for making them too flat, but having played them at 11 on the stimp, I am now satisfied that it was the right decision.  There is sufficient movement to keep them interesting and there are lots of pinning options, but they never get too crazy that they get out of control.  They are really tough greens to read because of the long contours and optical illusions can play havoc with your judgment.  A case in point is 17, which Scott described as being really steep.  Actually, it isn't.  It has a max of 2.5% slope and generally less in the hole location zones.  it just looks steeper owing to the surrounidng topography.  Consequently, everybody allows too much break.   The course has just been given a slope of 153 off the back tees!  It is tough enough without having tricked up greens.  Get it on the putting surface and you feel you have a chance to make a putt.

It's a fun course to play.  I hope that a few more people get the chance now, given the prospect that the gates will be opened, albeit very selectively.
2024: RSt.D; Mill Ride; Milford; Notts; JCB, Jameson Links, Druids Glen, Royal Dublin, Portmarnock, Old Head, Addington, Parkstone, Denham, Thurlestone, Dartmouth, Rustic Canyon, LACC (N), MPCC (Shore), Cal Club, San Fran, Epsom, Casa Serena, Hayling, Co. Sligo, Strandhill, Carne, Cleeve Hill

Ben Stephens

  • Karma: +0/-0
Robin,

I did not bring up the chance to talk about Casa Serena yesterday. From the images I have seen I think you have done a great job here and I would definitely not use a driver on some holes as it is all about placement on some holes which adds interest and makes you think more how to approach a certain hole. I have never played on fully bent grass greens and would love to try it out if I ever get the chance to go to the Czech Rep.

Cheers
Ben

Matt Day

  • Karma: +0/-0
Is the structure in the 17th fairway (par 3) a well?


Scott Warren

  • Karma: +0/-0
Matt,

Yes, it's a well.

There's a great story behind it that I'll leave it to Robin to tell.

Adam Lawrence

  • Karma: +0/-0

Scott is too modest to mention that he won the tournament being held that day for the assembled media, who were there to promote the forthcoming European Senior Tour event.  Scott was the only person to play to their handicap all day, totting up 36 stableford points.  I hope to see him wearing the bright red 'Casa Serena Open' rainjacket with pride someday soon!

My only real issue is aesthetic - the scale of the contouring makes the bunkers seem a little bit understated. But since Robin was working with a construction crew that didn't have any experience of shaping on this kind of scale, that's understandable. And maybe the greens are a little understated also, but given he knew the client wanted to be able to get them up to very high speeds, it was probably a sensible decision.


As ever, Adam makes very fair and well considered comments.  I had a real desire to give the bunkers a more naturalised look, but when it came to marking them out I just could not convince myself that it was the right thing to do here.  Given the purpose of the course as a private retreat, I just didn't feel that 84 frenzied looking bunkers was conducive to the relaxation and enjoyment the course was intended to promote.  I believe I made the right decision.

The greens contouring was a similar case study.  They were my first pure bent greens, having previously done all fescue/bent greens in the UK and Northern Europe.  It was always intended that they would run fast and I really had to throttle back my natural instincts to throw the surfaces about a bit.  All through construction and grow in I was telling myself off for making them too flat, but having played them at 11 on the stimp, I am now satisfied that it was the right decision.  There is sufficient movement to keep them interesting and there are lots of pinning options, but they never get too crazy that they get out of control.  They are really tough greens to read because of the long contours and optical illusions can play havoc with your judgment.  A case in point is 17, which Scott described as being really steep.  Actually, it isn't.  It has a max of 2.5% slope and generally less in the hole location zones.  it just looks steeper owing to the surrounidng topography.  Consequently, everybody allows too much break. 

By 'everyone' he means me. I had a monster eagle putt on the fourteenth hole which I completely misread and, although I got the pace pretty much dead, left about 20 feet right of the hole. Bah.
Adam Lawrence

Editor, Golf Course Architecture
www.golfcoursearchitecture.net

Principal, Oxford Golf Consulting
www.oxfordgolfconsulting.com

Author, 'More Enduring Than Brass: a biography of Harry Colt' (forthcoming).

Short words are best, and the old words, when short, are the best of all.

Scott Warren

  • Karma: +0/-0
We hope to have video footage on YouTube very soon!

Of course what you lose in admitting you putted it 20ft right of the hole you gain in dropping in that that offending roll was for eagle...

Robin_Hiseman

  • Karma: +0/-0
Ben

On most holes I reckon you wouldn't be able to resist the big stick, but having seen how far you bomb it, I might make you play off the back set.  It's a different course entirely from back there.

Matt

Yes, it is a well.  We had absolutely no idea it existed, as it was found, completely by accident, with the very last scrape of a 2.5 metre deep cut we were making.  The dozer picked up this giant coping stone with its last push and revelaed this enormous hole.  The archaeologists came out for a look but it wasn't old enough for them to be too interested.  It's probably 400-500 years old, but quite how it got so deep down in the subsoil is anybody's guess.  Fortunately, we found it in exactly the right position to make a nice feature of it without it getting in the way.  It's quite the talking point and everybody stops to have a look down.  It is at least 10 metres deep and beautifully built.  
2024: RSt.D; Mill Ride; Milford; Notts; JCB, Jameson Links, Druids Glen, Royal Dublin, Portmarnock, Old Head, Addington, Parkstone, Denham, Thurlestone, Dartmouth, Rustic Canyon, LACC (N), MPCC (Shore), Cal Club, San Fran, Epsom, Casa Serena, Hayling, Co. Sligo, Strandhill, Carne, Cleeve Hill

Tags:
Tags:

An Error Has Occurred!

Call to undefined function theme_linktree()
Back