I was very impressed with Old Macdonald. It would not surprise me one bit that this becomes the 'favorite' golf course at Bandon Dunes, surpassing Pacific Dunes, which everyone seems to feel 'was' the best.
In my book, the four courses are all spectacular and make my list of best personal Modern golf courses.
To rank them, however, would be like having someone ask you if you would like:
1 $1,000,000 in cash
2 $1,000,001 in cash
3 $1,000,002 in cash
4 $1,000,003 in cash
in each case, the answer is 'yes' and I wouldn't gripe about taking any of them!