I guess I am not as motivated to see Carnoustie. Though the course did not treat my game well today, I know that I would be traveling a few hundred miles to get my ass kicked if I went to Carnasty. Either trip beats wasting money club cover charges in London, though.
John, I think you're doing Carnoustie a great disservice. Carnoustie has the 'Carnasty' reputation following the 1999 Open Championship yet the condition of the course (let's say 'rough') is nothing like that outside Open conditions. The course is probably left off peoples bucket list because of the bad rap it got from some whinging Pro's in '99
, and I, for one, say more fool those who avoid it.
People often talk glowingly of the last three holes on the Championship course, but in my view, 13 - 18 are as good a collection of continuous holes as you will find in the UK. Please don't let an 11 year old whinge-fest cloud your judgement.
As for the journey, here's my view. Take the sleeper to Edinburgh (as mentioned by others) on a Friday night then take the first train to Leuchars on Saturday morning. Take a bus or taxi to St Andrews and try for a spot on the Old. PM me if you have trouble here – I MAY be able to help if you give me some notice. There's a great B&B for 30 quid about 200 metres from the 1st tee. It's by far, the cheapest place in town and a semi-hidden secret. After golf, there’s tonnes of time for a round on the New or Jubilee courses (not the Castle joke
), or just wander around town enjoying the sights, and possibly the Golf museum. Remember, the Old will close 6 weeks or so before the Open so check with the St Andrews Links Trust.
On Sunday, take the bus to Dundee and the train to Carnousite Golf Street where it is a short walk to the course.
In the evening, check the trains south as there may be one that stops in Carnoustie (town centre, not Golf Street) where you will have an uninterrupted trip to London and can write about your adventure ready to post to your GCA buddies here.
And finally, it would be a mistake leaving London without finding your way on to the Old and New courses at Sunningdale, and that is a very do-able double in one day from London. Train from Waterloo to Sunniingdale.) If you can find a member to help with the green fee, even better.
Good luck!