I have not played any of the Top 50, but I have walked around Cherry Hills quite a bit and can't believe there's any reason it would make such a list were it not for the '60 US Open factor. It's a fine course, I guess, but I have at least visited several other Top 50 courses and CH isn't in the same neighborhood.
I have played Kapalua Pantation, which several previously mentioned as a potential Top 50 replacement, and it was far and above CH.