I think the posts above clearly describe the way GCA can serve the many tastes of the game's players. Perhaps it even provides an example of strategic vs. penal architecture styles.
The strategic choices made on TOC 18th tee is one form of engagement or perhaps entertainment for the player. Is there really one "best" way to play the hole?
On the other hand, when playing the 18th at MVCC, the "best" choice for the player has been predetermined by the architect. Any line other than the best line will incrementally penalize the player for not making the right choice and the right shot.
Looking at Kalen's overhead view, and remembering my one and only trip to MVCC with a tour of the course provided by Desmond Muirhead, I believe that the "best" (not the only) line to play is to the right side of the fairway, tempting the bunkers. This opens the green up and shortens the shot required. The trick is to have the ball stay on the right side of the fairway, as it is canted from right to left. To do that the player should probably play a fade off the tee.
So, following Jim Murray's philosophy, this great finishing hole will separate the thinkers and shot shapers from the rest of the field.