Ian
First of all my comment re GPS was mean to be amusing clearly you did not see the humour.
As for Trees on fairways, I have already stated that they are the Jokers in the pack. Their appearance in the first place, combined with their growth and future shape, I would guess have not been calculated by the designer thus may affect the other hazards on that hole. As the tree develops, the choices may vary thus deviating from the architects original intentions for that hole, rendering it’s a potential pain in the bum hole (which if funds are available may well be modified to correct the problem). Although not in course design, I have spent some years designing projects and would never include a potential joker in my designs. I do not believe any quality designer would leave his/her design open to potential criticism in this way.
I do not know how you view things, but if I feel it is wrong its does not matter where in the world it is, it’s still wrong. Be it on TOC or in the middle of America, it makes no difference. I do not criticise people because of their Nationality, Race or Religion. To say, “I am guessing that if there was a tree on a fairway on The Old Course you would have a different opinion.” Just goes to show the type of individual you are and only reflect upon you.
Trees generate that unknown factor, their shape, prone to deformity be it natural, man or storm inflicted, worst of all the volume of water they consume from the area around their base. Then we have the potential of conflicting with design intent, come on Ian I must have explained enough reason why I am not keen re trees on or near the fairway. They should be out passed the rough, if you are stuck with them.
Just in case I am not clear, I confirm that my answer is NO I would not want or like that tree on TOC.
I am sorry you feel that you need to call me twofaced, hopefully your vision has re-focused and you now see clearly.
Melvyn