News:

Welcome to the Golf Club Atlas Discussion Group!

Each user is approved by the Golf Club Atlas editorial staff. For any new inquiries, please contact us.


Phil McDade

  • Karma: +0/-0
A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« on: August 18, 2009, 09:33:22 AM »
Beverly Country Club, in the heart of Chicago’s South Side, will host this year’s USGA Senior Amateur Championship Sept. 12-17. The Donald Ross course has hosted several significant championships over the years, including four Western Opens and the 1931 U.S. Amateur won by the great Francis Ouimet.

For a variety of reasons, the course stopped hosting significant championships after 1970, despite its pedigree. But a major renovation led by architect Ron Prichard, and a renewed commitment by the club’s membership to hosting championships, has again put the course back in the limelight. The nation’s best senior amateurs should be well-tested by this demanding layout.

The course is divided in half by 87th Street – the front nine and pro shop on the north side of the street, the back nine and clubhouse on the south side. A narrow tunnel underneath 87th Street connects the nines. The original course, first played in 1908, was revised dramatically when the club brought in Ross to oversee a master plan in 1917. Working with two long, narrow, rectangular pieces of land, Ross designed a course viewed by many as one of his best routing works.

Course details: Beverly plays to a par of 71, with five par 3s, four par 5s, and 9 par 4s. From the tips, the course plays to 7,016 yards (rating 74.2, slope 137). It plays at 6,849 yards from the blues (73.4/135) and 6,563 yards from the traditional member’s tees (72.1/132). It also has a set of tees at 6,237 yards.

The course’s most notable feature is one the golfer can’t see – the sandy base of soil upon which the course sits. Beverly is located on land that was once part of Lake Chicago. The receding glacier left a sandy base that allows the course to drain exceedingly well, and thus it plays faster and firmer than the green fairways might suggest. One of the lake’s shorelines formed a major ridge that comes into play on the front nine, while the sandy dunes left by the receding glacier created the rolling terrain that mark several holes on the back nine.

The course is in the traditional American parkland style, with trees often framing fairway corridors. As part of the Prichard renovation, hundreds of trees were removed, opening up interior course views and widening fairway corridors. But trees still play a significant role in the look of the course, and often come into play with wayward shots.

(Information for this thread comes from the GCA “Courses by Country” review of Beverly, discussions with Beverly members at the U.S. Senior Amateur media day Aug. 12, and particularly Tim Cronin’s excellent 100-year history of the club, “Beverly’s First Century: The country club in the city.” Many thanks also to Beverly members Terry Lavin – a GCA contributor – and Steve Coates for extending an invitation to the media day and serving as wonderful hosts.)

On to the first tee (yardages from the championship, blue, and white member tees):

No. 1 (par 4, 356/356/349)

Ross suggested a course’s first hole ought to resemble a friendly handshake – not overly taxing, and an introduction of what’s to come. The 1st here fits the bill – a short par 4 with a fairway bunker short-right and another longer left. Interestingly, the hole pre-dates Ross’ involvement at Beverly, but he apparently liked it well enough to leave it as the opener.


A well-placed bunker short of the green right hides a good portion of the green, which is guarded by two deep bunkers left and another deep one right.


A classic Ross green – perched up, tilted sternly from back to front, and trouble all around, particularly long.


No. 2 (par 5, 582/550/533)

The ridge line comes into play dramatically at the 2nd; the back tee is the highest point in all of Chicago. The hole, after diving into the valley off the tee, sweeps to the left.


The golfer has to thread his way through a series of fairway bunkers to find the green in the distance.


No. 3 (par 3, 245/222/198)

A very long par 3 over flat terrain, with two bunkers left and a bunker right waiting the errant shot. This is a hole where the skilled player can run the ball up to the green. The hole plays in the opposite direction of the par 5 corridor of the 2nd – Ross managed to route only two holes in the same direction during the entire round, forcing the player to constantly account for the day’s wind direction.


A look at the 3rd green, relatively flat by Beverly standards.


No. 4 (par 4, 399/395/386)

The golfer is now in the far north-eastern corner of the property, so Ross designed a dogleg left of medium length. The fence that marks the edge of the course can be disconcerting at first glance; long hitters can easily reach it. Prichard placed a large, gathering bunker at the inside corner of the dogleg to make the golfer think carefully about his choice of clubs and line on the tee. The row houses of 83rd Street can be seen beyond the fence – one rarely escapes the sense at Beverly that you’re playing a round of golf in a distinctly urban environment.


The approach shot at the 4th. For me, the course really starts to rev up here; with few exceptions, there is rarely a dull shot, or one that doesn’t require some thought, for the rest of the round. The approach to the 4th is a demanding second shot, to a perched-up green nearly completely encircled by sand, with OB looming hard right.


No. 5 (par 4, 415/412/398)

A medium-length par 4 that plays longer than its yardage as it flows uphill the entire way. The hole ends  on top of the ridge line, no doubt viewed as a perfect green site by Ross. Golfers must place their drives in the fairway if they hope to reach the green with their second shot.


The 5th green from where a solid drive might end up. Deep bunkers left and right gobble up the less-than-well struck approach shot.


The green tilts significantly from back to front; just to the left of the caddie walking off the green is a sharply slanted back portion of the green re-captured as part of the recent renovation.


A look back at the 5th – a solid par 4 that probably gets less notice than many of the course’s other two-shotters.


No. 6 (par 3, 189/181/169)

A difficult target hole, with a perched-up green surrounded on three sides by sand and a steep falloff back. One of the challenges of this hole is that the tee sits atop the ridge line, with the green in the valley below. The golfer on the tee has to make a precise stroke, but judging the wind can be difficult, as almost any tee shot will quickly soar above the tree line. Judging the wind from the flag on the green below seems to be of little help. As is often the case with greens surrounded entirely by trouble (see Lawsonia’s 7th), the green is actually larger than what it appears to be on the tee.


No. 7 (par 5, 574/561/529)

The most-photographed hole at Beverly, and one of its best. After routing Beverly’s first par 5 from the top of the ridge line to the valley, Ross routed the second par 5 from the valley up and over the ridge line. From the tips, the carry to the top of the ridge line is about 250 yards uphill; bunkers are placed halfway up the hill to catch errant drives. Yes, the ball will roll back down the hill.


If carrying the hill wasn’t a chore enough, the 7th features trees on both sides of the fairway that feel much closer than the trees framing other fairways on the front nine. It’s a hole that requires both length and accuracy.


These two bunkers, squeezing the fairway some 75 yards in front of the green, were added by Prichard to add a dimension of trouble for those going for the green in two.


No. 8 (par 4, 424/424/403)

Some of the best bunkering schemes on the course can be found on the 8th, a medium-length hole full of trouble and interest. The tee shot must be threaded between a bunker right and one farther down the fairway left.


Once past those, the golfer will be confronted with another series of bunkers, including a centerline trap for the too-bold tee shot. But the most interesting, and jarring, look is up ahead – there’s a huge expanse of green, but the pin (red flag) is tucked behind a bunker left.


Here’s the pin – placed on the front portion of a 65-yard deep green. The front third of the green is from Ross; the remaining back two-third’s was added prior to the 1963 Western Open at Beverly. Prichard left the expanded green intact.


Another look at the 8th green – with three distinct tiers, and surrounded by not one grain of sand, it’s one of Beverly’s most distinctive greens.


No. 9 (par 4, 413/410/403)

A hole that had to be adjusted following the expansion of 87th Street to a four-lane road in the 1930s. The green, originally sited by Ross to sit right behind the 7th green and next to the 1st tee, was moved north and back toward the 9th tee as part of the road project.  The hole plays similarly to the 4th – a dogleg left, with a bunker guarding the inside of the dogleg.


The approach to the 9th, over flat ground.


Back nine to follow.
« Last Edit: August 18, 2009, 12:12:41 PM by Phil McDade »

Phil McDade

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #1 on: August 18, 2009, 09:38:51 AM »
Beverly's back nine:

No. 10 (par 3, 198/193/180)

The golfer, after negotiating the tunnel underneath 87th Street, winds his way to the backside of the Beverly clubhouse and the start of the back nine. The 10th tee sits adjacent to the clubhouse, and was – in the very first year the course opened, as a nine-holer – the opening hole.


The 10th hole is in a beautiful setting in the upper left corner of the back-nine property. The play is a long-iron or fairway wood to a green that is guarded by fronting bunkers left and right, and features a strong back-to-front tilt.


When asked for advice on how to play Beverly, veteran members of the club will invariably say: “Keep it below the hole.” This ball must go through 10 feet of fringe to a pin in the middle of the green. Still, saving par from this position may be easier than a ball on the green that’s above the flag.


No. 11 (par 5, 604/584/572)

A long, tough par 5 over rolling terrain. The tee shot is somewhat obscured, but used to be completely blind over a hill that was removed – after years of argument among the club membership – in the 1950s at the urging of one Robert Bruce Harris. The rail line that forms the entire western border of the course parallels the length of the hole. One interesting characteristic of Beverly’s first three par 5s is that – even at 582, 574, and 604 yards (from the tips) – they all play tighter than most of the course’s par 4s because of the tree corridors.


Who’s that man in the red hat (black shorts, white shirt)? Why, it’s Stan Mikita. You know you’re in Chicago when…


The long second at the 11th. The pinching fairway bunker left was added by Prichard.


The approach to the 11th allows for a running shot into a green trapped left and right.


The characteristic slant of a Ross green at Beverly.


No. 12 (par 3, 165/160/142)

A terrific short par 3: a target shot to a wild green with all kinds of trouble everywhere you look – water, deep sand pits, and OB right next door.


Here’s a fun little bunker shot.


Although difficult to depict in this light and shadows, the green on 12 is two-tiered – slanted toward the pond in the front half, but away from the tee in the back half (with a steep drop-off to boot). Arriving safely on this green is arguably not even half the battle – a tough green to read and putt.


No. 13 (par 4, 385/385/374)

The first of two very enjoyable sub-400-yard par 4s. For my tastes, few shots are as fun as a blind tee shot, with the outcome uncertain until you’ve walked well beyond the tee. One the major changes initiated by Ross on the back nine was to move the 13th tee from atop the hill to behind it, creating the blind tee shot. Prichard moved the fairway a bit left, away from the OB that lines the entire right side of the hole, but the threat still looms for the wayward driver.


The crest of the hill reveals a broad, accommodating fairway that runs across the valley to a classic Ross greensite – perched up from the fairway, pinched by bunkers. Ouimet clinched his Amateur win on this hole, as did Chick Evans in the first Western Open hosted by the club in 1910.


A look back at the 13th fairway and the hill that must be carried. Ross, in moving the tee back behind the hill, maintained the strategic nature of the blind tee shot here – the uncertainty faced by the golfer on the tee is balanced by offering plenty of room for the tee shot landing area.


No. 14 (par 4, 333/333/327)

All great courses should feature at least one very good short par 4 – and the 14th is Beverly’s. A surprisingly wide fairway is pinched about 230 yards from the tee by bunkers left and right – play short, squeeze a drive in between, or blast a drive over them? Regardless of the choice, the tee ball needs to be in the fairway, because…


…the approach shot is one of the most demanding on the course, to a severely pushed-up green, with a huge tilt from back to front, and deep bunkers fronting the green and on both sides.


The 14th green, which slightly resembles a saucer tilted at an angle toward the fairway. Along with the 12th, I found this to be a very difficult green to read.


From atop the nearby 17th tee, the benefits of the tree clearance program can be seen in the open vistas on parts of the course.  Here is a view of the parallel 13th and 14th fairways.


No. 15 (par 4, 465/465/454)

Ross boasted that the final four holes at Beverly would be known as the finest finishing stretch in Chicago. It starts here with perhaps the most rugged hole on the course. Tee shots that fail to reach the crest of the rise in the distance will trickle off to the left, leaving a blind second. On a course where level  lies in the fairway are often the norm, the 15th fairway offers few even stances for the golfer’s second shot. For veteran Beverly members, the tree clearance program may be most noticeable here – the trees used to form a canopy over the 15th fairway. Still, there is a sense on the part of the player of the strict need to stay on the fairway, because a number of mature trees lurk not far into the rough.


The rolling fairway of the 15th.


The 15th green, guarded by two enormous trees. Beverly members point to the benefits of green conditioning that resulted from opening up areas of the course to sunlight.


A look back at the 15th hole.


No. 16 (par 4, 441/434/405)

The 16th runs in the opposite direction of the 15th, over more level terrain, with a fairway that gradually rises to a green benched against the side of a small hill. A lone fairway bunker right guides the player to the left portion of the fairway, which is the better side to take on the demanding second shot.


Two looks at the approach to the 16th green; in the first photo, the large trees on the right tend to obscure the hill that Ross used to great effect in positioning the green. The second photo demonstrates that although a narrow run-up option exists, the penal green surrounds suggest an aerial shot to hold the tilted green is the best approach.



A look from behind the 16th green; one hopes the tree-clearance effort at Beverly continues by getting rid of the all the trees cluttering up the wonderful natural feature of the hill next to this green.


No. 17 (par 3, 229/209/202)

An elevated tee provides a clear view of the options on this long par 3 – fly it to the green, or run up a shot in the corridor that snakes through the bunkers. Members have long favored hitting to a spot left and short of the green – known as Cavvy’s Corner – and trying to get up and down from there. It’s a better risk, they say, than being above the pin on what is one of the most severely canted greens on the course.


No. 18 (par 5, 599/575/557)

Beverly’s rugged finish concludes with this terrific three-shotter. The tee shot is to a broad, green bunkerless plain, with the hole then doglegging right all the way up to the clubhouse.


Here’s the turn of the dogleg.


Those playing aggressively with their second shots must thread their way past deep fairway bunkers left and right.


The third-shot approach to the 18th green, with bunkers left and right in the classic Ross style at Beverly.


The severe tilt of the 18th green; Prichard’s restoration captured additional green space here. Members have a wonderful vantage point of the 18th green from the veranda attached to the clubhouse; it’s not unusual, they’ll tell you with a glint in their eye, to see first-time players at Beverly (or forgetful ones) putt their ball off the green from above the pin.


Sunset at the finishing hole.


Perhaps it’s a cliché, but it’s true – Beverly is like the town it calls home: a tough, muscular course, without pretense or artifice, nothing gimmicky or tricked-up. Its challenges are readily evident; it rewards well-struck shots and punishes poor ones from the first tee to the 18th green. The Ross greens demand careful and constant attention. And, to top it all off, the clubhouse serves Italian sausages with peppers. At a time when cookie-cutter courses dot the landscape, it’s hard to imagine Beverly Country Club anywhere else but Chicago.



K. Krahenbuhl

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #2 on: August 18, 2009, 09:44:26 AM »
Beverly is one of my all time favorites.  I really like the stretch of 5-8 on the front nine and 15-18 on the back.  I've yet to play it this year, but I can see from the photographs that the conditioning will be top notch for the over 50 crowd next month.

Chip Gaskins

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #3 on: August 18, 2009, 09:53:50 AM »
Phil & Kyle -

I agree with your praise.  I played it a month or so ago and thoroughly enjoyed it.

The par 3 #6 is a fantastic hole and the green complex on #14 world class.

Very very good golf course!

Chip

tlavin

Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #4 on: August 18, 2009, 10:07:19 AM »
Phil,

Thanks for the post; the photography does show the course well.  We had a nice, pleasant Media Day and are looking forward to the Senior Amateur in less than a month.  It will be interesting to see the course host another competitive event.  The Seniors are only playing the course at 6500 yards, but the greens will be rolling at 11 and I doubt that they'll tear it up.

Adam Clayman

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #5 on: August 18, 2009, 11:34:10 AM »
One of the more subtle examples of quality. The "wow" factor that infects so many gca novices will not be evident until the observer is no longer a novice.

Just another stupid post from Adam Clayman. 
"It's unbelievable how much you don't know about the game you've been playing your whole life." - Mickey Mantle

Peter Pallotta

Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #6 on: August 18, 2009, 12:19:43 PM »
Thank you, Phil. Really good pictures (especially in how they show-off the architecture).

Amazing how far sandy soils go to helping ensure a good (and often great) golf course, and almost always an aesthetically-pleasing one too.

Peter

Tyler Kearns

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #7 on: August 18, 2009, 01:10:48 PM »
The golf course looks great, a testament to Ross' original design, and the restorative efforts of Ron Prichard. The grassing lines look very good, with fairways running out in front of the bunkers as intended.
The first post notes the shortest tees as 6,237 yards!! Is that the shortest set?

TK

Paul Richards

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #8 on: August 18, 2009, 01:17:27 PM »
Phil:

Thank you for a great presentation.

Beverly is in fabulous shape for the USGA Senior Amateur - I have had people say it is in the best shape in 40 years!  Keith Peterson is our Super and deserves kudos.  

This event will be the second USGA event held at Beverly, with Francis Ouimet winning the 1931 National Amateur.  Hopefully, 2009 will produce as great a champion!

Special thanks to our golf course architect, Ron Prichard, for bringing Donald Ross back to Beverly.

And also special thanks to Golfweek Magazine for the national recognition afforded this spectacular golf course, by putting it on the Golfweek Top 100 Classic List for each year, beginning in 2005.


 :)
« Last Edit: August 18, 2009, 01:22:21 PM by Paul Richards »
"Something has to change, otherwise the never-ending arms race that benefits only a few manufacturers will continue to lead to longer courses, narrower fairways, smaller greens, more rough, more expensive rounds, and other mechanisms that will leave golf's future in doubt." -  TFOG

Phil McDade

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #9 on: August 18, 2009, 01:56:01 PM »
Peter:

The sandy divots at Beverly were really neat -- as one who plays a variety of courses in the region, it's just not something you expect at an otherwise parkland-style course in the Midwest.

Tyler:

There are a set of red tees at Beverly; they weren't listed on the scorecard provided for the media day there last week (you can see a few of the red tees on some of the pictures of tee shots, like the 18th). The club history says that the red tees run around 6,000 yards, give or take. (The green tees are rated 70.6/128.) Beverly has a very distinguished history of women's golf -- Virginia Van Wie, who learned to play the game at the club, won three straight U.S. Women's Amateurs in the 1930s. The club has also hosted three Women's Western Open, the first professional major for women.

Tiger_Bernhardt

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #10 on: August 18, 2009, 02:28:18 PM »
Two Indian heads in one post is amazing. Paul I cannot believe a long Beverly post took this long for you to notice.  cheers and 19 days to kickoff.

Chris Buie

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #11 on: August 18, 2009, 03:08:56 PM »
Nice job Phil.  Some of the fairways look pretty tight.  I wonder if that is a USGA thing or if they usually play like that. 
A 65 yard green!  I think I might have to seriously consider pitching the ball rather than putting if I was left with a shot that was the full length of that green.

Ash Towe

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #12 on: August 18, 2009, 03:09:55 PM »
Phil,
Thanks for the photo tour.  I had the great pleasure of playing there last month.  It was a real surprise to even find a course in that part of the city never mind one of such quality.
The conditions are indeed of the highest level.  Those playing in the Seniors will  have a fine old time.
I hope this event leads to other Senior events being played there.

Phil McDade

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #13 on: August 18, 2009, 03:28:53 PM »
Nice job Phil.  Some of the fairways look pretty tight.  I wonder if that is a USGA thing or if they usually play like that. 
A 65 yard green!  I think I might have to seriously consider pitching the ball rather than putting if I was left with a shot that was the full length of that green.

Chris:

I'm a pretty wayward driver of the ball, and I really didn't feel all that constrained by the fairway corridors there -- notable exceptions might be 5, where being off the fairway really leaves you with little chance at hitting that green sitting on the ridge; 7 to some extent (not necessarily on the tee shot, but the second needs to stay straight); 11 and 15 especially -- 11 just feels real tight, because the OB right is a constant presence, and 15, because the fairway contours there (really, the only place at Beverly where this might happen) can propel a ball off the fairway, and the trees are pretty close. The dogleg par 4s -- 4 and 9 -- are less tight than they are shortish holes where the longer hitter it seems either has to hit something other than driver off the tee, or work the ball off the tee. But they aren't tight in the traditional sense. Others on the board may know better than I, but I think the course played last week in terms of fairway width will play pretty much as it will be presented for the Senior AMs, with the exception that green speeds will be somewhat quicker.

That green at 8 is something to see -- it's a pretty neat thing to crest that small rise in the fairway, look past all the bunkering there, and see such a large green. I have little doubt that the USGA will have some really varied pin positions there -- some up front, and some waaay back.

Brian Joines

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #14 on: August 18, 2009, 04:04:19 PM »
Thanks for the great photo tour. I've haven't been fortunate enough to play out here but the course looks to be great fun. I immediately noticed how much it reminds me of Skokie. I guess that makes sense with Prichard doing a Ross restoration of both courses. It's always hard to tell from the pictures but the corridors seem to be wide enough to give you some options off of the tee. The greens look like a blast!

I've always been interested in Beverly because the original design was by George O'Neil I believe. He designed my home course (South Bend CC, South Bend, IN) and there's very little of his work left anywhere to see. How many of his original holes still remain part of the routing? I'm guessing there isn't much more of his work left besides a few holes Ross decided to incorporate into his design.

Thanks again for the great thread. I look forward to seeing it for myself somewhere down the line.

Phil McDade

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #15 on: August 18, 2009, 04:50:52 PM »
Brian:

O'Neil's involvement with Beverly is really interesting stuff (much of the following comes from Tim Cronin's 100-year anniversary history of Beverly). Three clubs around the turn of the century decided they needed more room for a common golf course, as development in the city of Chicago was encroaching upon their courses. One of the courses was Auburn Park, whose head pro was O'Neil. Representatives from the three clubs authorized a purchase of land, and one of the sites scouted out were two large parcels of mostly farmland and woods on either side of 87th Street just west of Western Avenue on the city's (then) far south side.

O'Neil was said to have walked the current Beverly property with Chicago architect Tom Bendelow and perhaps two other members of Auburn Park. It was viewed as ideal land for an 18-hole course. The representatives of the three clubs -- now known as Beverly CC -- bought the land, with some speculation that they beat to the punch a group of like-minded golfers who eventually bought land that would become Idlewild CC on the city's far southern reaches in Flossmor.

The story goes that O'Neil, along with an influential early Beverly member named George Janes, and a John Middleton trudged through the Beverly property on a cold winter day, working out a routing (there is no confirmed record of Bendelow being involved in the routing). O'Neil, Beverly's first professional and also its greenskeeper, is given the lion's share of the credit for the routing, esp. on the back nine. What's truly fascinating about O'Neil's routing is that nearly half of it remains -- the 1st is pretty much as he routed it, and what is now the 8th follows one of his holes. Holes 10 through 16 largely follow his original routing -- with the major exception of the changed teeing ground of the 13th (Ross). (Ross also substantially changed the 11th and 12th hole green sites.) O'Neil's initial routing of the front nine and the last two holes of the back nine was compromised somewhat because the club didn't own all the land it does now -- by the time the club contracted with Ross in 1917, it had added more land to both the northern and southern parcels of land, giving Ross much more flexibility than O'Neil had. By the time Ross was at Beverly working on his extensive renovations, O'Neil had moved on to South Bend, where he was hired by the founders of the South Bend Country Club to design their course. After a year there, he moved on to become the pro at Chicago's Lake Shore CC, having had his contract at South Bend bought out by a wealthy Chicago businessman who admired his work.



« Last Edit: August 18, 2009, 11:43:27 PM by Phil McDade »

Brian Joines

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #16 on: August 18, 2009, 05:40:11 PM »
Phil,

Thanks for all of the information. That sounds like a an excellent book! That's interesting that nearly half of O'Neil's routing remained in place. How extensive was Ross' renovation? Of the holes he kept from O'Neil's routing, what other types of changes were made? Were all the bunkers redone as well or are some of the holes pretty close to his original design?


Dean Stokes

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #17 on: August 18, 2009, 06:12:24 PM »
Looks like a course I would like to play everyday. I'm surprised that we haven't seen a post yet from the anti - tree brigade. Although I really enjoy tree lined golf courses, many on this site seem to despise tight, treed golf courses.

Living The Dream in The Palm Beaches....golfing, yoga-ing, horsing around and working damn it!!!!!!!

Dan Moore

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #18 on: August 18, 2009, 07:18:11 PM »
There are not many courses where you can say the par 5's are the strength of the course but that is surely the case at BCC.  I also really liked the gospel soul music being played in the Forest Preserve across the street.  Mighty Sam McClain if I'm not mistaken.  Harvie Ward liked to hum swing band music to find his rhythm, I think Mighty Sam helped me find mine at BCC.   
"Is there any other game which produces in the human mind such enviable insanity."  Bernard Darwin

Phil McDade

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #19 on: August 18, 2009, 07:25:36 PM »
Brian:

Ross extensively re-did much of the routing on the front nine (excluding #1). He took advantage of the additional land the club had acquired by then to route holes 2 through 4. One of the main things he did was take advantage of the wonderful ridge line that cuts across the northern half of the property (from east to west), which provided for the thrilling tee shot of the 2nd, the climbing, uphill nature of the 5th with a green perched on top of the ridge line, the tee shot of the 6th on top the ridge to a green below, and the sharply uphill ridge that one has to carry with the tee shot on 7. I've read a lot about Ross' skill as a router, and his use of the ridge line on the front nine really does reveal his abilities to take advantage of the terrain.

On the back nine, additional land allowed Ross to route the two closing holes, which are very strong. He also, as mentioned, re-sited some greens, notably 11 and 12, but also I believe 15. The course also has eliminated over the years two ponds -- one fronting the 16th tee, and one in front of the old 9th green.

My sense, without having alot of knowledge of playing Ross greens (but having read up on them), is that nearly every green out there was re-done by Ross. My sense also, and others with more familiarity will certainly know more, is that alot of the bunkering work was done by Ross -- Tim Cronin's history of the club suggests the club thought it had a nice course with O'Neil's original work, but not a championship one, and in particular the course came under some criticism (by its own members!) for lacking a certain toughness, particularly in bunkering, found in other Chicago-area courses.


J_ Crisham

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #20 on: August 18, 2009, 07:30:36 PM »
Dan,  Glad you enjoyed yourself! You drove the ball very nicely. An 80 the 1st time around is good stuff. 
Wish you well,     Jack

J_ Crisham

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #21 on: August 18, 2009, 07:45:44 PM »
Phil,   Thanks for a very nice review! Not to nitpick but the fairway bunker that you have pictured on #11 is not the one that was added recently. The bunker you have pictured is about 235yds from the green. I can recall watching Charley Penna hit 2 woods from that bunker to the green while practicing.  The bunker you are referring to is about 240yds off the tee. I have been in it the last two weekends! :(     Wish you well,   Jack

JWinick

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #22 on: August 18, 2009, 08:37:33 PM »
Beverly is a great achievement - the architect got as much out of the site as possible.   One couldn't possibly come up with a better routing.   

Love the Par 5s, but wish there was one I had a shot to get to in two!  Each one is a true three-shotter.   

Probably as good a caddy program as anywhere.   The club has produced more Evans Scholars than any other club.   

Greens are challenging.  Jack, how fast do you think they will roll for the amateur?   And, what speed do the members usually play them at?  I can imagine that these greens would be extremely difficult at very high speeds. 

And, Dan's 80 was legitimate.... Thanx, Jack, for a great time.   

John Mayhugh

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #23 on: August 18, 2009, 09:41:28 PM »
Thanks for all the pics, Phil.   Looks great.

john_stiles

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: A country club in the city -- Ross' Beverly CC in Chicago
« Reply #24 on: August 18, 2009, 10:03:17 PM »
Wonderful course and membership.     The work by Ron Prichard really made the features jump back out in my opinion, with the bunker work, green areas restored and all the tree removal/limbing.

Am sure the greens will hold off low scores, but if playing at 6500 yards,  it will be short-ish for the seniors.

Paul Richards and others have done a first rate job with the history displays in the clubhouse.


« Last Edit: August 18, 2009, 10:38:56 PM by john_stiles »