John - I too was expecting a wedge, and thought back to Pebble in 1982. When I saw the putter, I felt like Watson had lost his nerve and I had a bad feeling. It seemed like the "old guy" club pull.
Gib, I think yesterday may have been the cruelest finish to a sporting event I have ever seen. I'm not even a huge Watson fan, but I think the only word for what I felt was grief. I mourned what could, and should, have been.