Ben - thanks for that enjoyable read. I'm glad to see Doug Carrick's name here -- first, because I like his work (I think he stands well above his Canadian counterparts) and second because he is one of the few name architects whose courses I've actually played (but even then, just those in the Toronto area). I think of Carrick as an exceptionally good craftsman, and as an astute (but sincere) popularizer of classic principles and/or modern trends; he has what I'd call 'good taste'. I particularly like (and appreciate the relatively good value of) the Osprey Valley courses and Ballantrae, I think he did a fine job with the new 9 at Nobleton, and I have a real soft spot for Copper Creek, even if from what I've heard it's the poor relation to Eagles Nest. (I've also played King Valley, and the Angus Glen courses). I hope to play Cobble Beach this summer -- once; I don't think I can/should play Eagles Nest, pocket-book wise.
Peter