The history of Orchard Park Country Club is an interesting one. Orchard Park Country Club was incorporated in 1946 shortly after its founders purchased the 1916 Travis course from Park Country Club. When Park CC had Travis design the course in Orchard Park they were situated on leased land in Buffalo that was not particularly desirable; plus their lease was scheduled to end in 1921. So, they were looking for an alternative location. For a period of time, Park CC maintained their Delaware Ave course in Buffalo and their "summer course" in Orchard Park. Then, for reasons not clear, they purchased land in Williamsville, NY, a northeasterly suburb of Buffalo. In 1924, Park CC asked Travis to assess this new land in terms of its suitability for a golf course. In his correspondence, Travis approved of the site with the proviso that they acquire some additional adjacent land. That course was designed by Colt and Allison in 1926 and construction was done by Harries and Hall. Afterwards, Park CC continued to be a two course club, but the depression took a huge toll on their revenues and membership, and despite various attempts, they had to relinquish the Orchard Park course. Thus, the sale of the Orchard Park course. As an aside, and addressing the Tillinghast recommendations, the Park CC's history book mentions that "in 1941, new tees were constructed at Orchard Park to bring the course up to the requirements of the PGA". The 5th hole recommendation by Tillinghast was not carried out (the hole he was referring to is now the 12th, and is in the same form as shown on early course maps).
I am in complete agreement with Ron's original nomination of the early 1990s renovation of OPCC by Ault as one of the worst. I had several opportunities to play the course before that renovation, and always felt that their two closing holes were among the best holes on the golf course. Their practice range, at the time, was located out in the area of the Ault created 5th hole and pond. They wanted a better practice range, and they sacrificed two of their best holes--plus an original par 3 that had some problems. Since the Ault renovation, some people have moved into positions of influence at OPCC who are aware and appreciative of the Travis connection. They wish to preserve what is left of the original course, and they support renovation efforts that are consistent with the classic nature of the original course. I believe that Renaissance Golf has had some influence at OPCC in recent years, and, possibly, Ian Andrew.
REgarding the question raised about purchasing additional land, per Tilly's recommendations: From maps I've seen that predate Tilly's visit, it does not appear that any property has been added, and it's hard to see where property could have been added--other than to the east, perhaps. The railroad and roads that border the property on the north, west, and south are the same as they existed originally, from what I can tell.
TMI??
Ed Homsey
Travis Society Archivist