Has anyone mentioned the 12th on Course 3 at Medinah? I can well imagine someone has, but if not: blind tee shot, fairway canted left to right with a slight left to right dogleg, to a green guarded with a tree on the left and a huge slope to a pond on the right. So, tee calls for a straight or fade shot, followed by a very long (200+ yds) second shot that must be either straight or drawn. Like all of Medinah’s heavy par fours (4 & 6, 12 & 16), it’s nearly 500 yards from the tips. Also like nearly all of Medinah’s holes, it’s a penal rather than strategic design (there’s only one real way to play it), but it is gorgeous, especially in the autumn—and the green might be one of the most difficult to putt on the entire course. Philosophically, it’s opposed to many ideas described on this site, but so what? To say that strategic golf is the only possible philosophy is arguably a tyranny of another sort—I certainly wouldn’t want to play it every day, but I wouldn’t want it changed either.