Jonathan, et al:
Be curious to see what courses are listed as the best public options within 30 miles of the nation's capital.
I like the Norman layout but it does have limitations because of the forced situation with the site it has.
Matt --
There have been several discussions of the DC area's lack of great golf courses, including this one:
http://golfclubatlas.com/forum/index.php/topic,35522.0.html.
I think the general consensus is that DC has no/few examples of world class (e.g., top 100) courses, and that the best in the area are private. On the public side, DC is dominated by mediocre/unnoteworthy munis and CCFADs with weekend rates of $80-110. Many of the CCFADS are good to very good, but rarely are they worth the combination of the cost and time to play (rounds here are very slow on the weekends, and often during the week as well). Many of these courses were not designed for walking either.
As both Ran and Doak have mentioned, DC is possibly the worst climate for growing gof turf in the country, so that hurts our cause as well. :-)
I've never played Lansdowne, in part because no one I know has raved about it enough for me to spend the $$$ they're asking for there.
That said, there are several public courses in our area that are worthy of your time and money. To my mind, these include:
* Laurel Hill – a very nice new muni by Bill Love built on the old Lorton Prison grounds, it’s not very walkable and it's priced/operated like a CCFAD. But that shouldn't detract from the outstanding routing and many wonderful golf holes.
* Glenn Dale – a mid-50s George Cobb course, see threads:
http://www.golfclubatlas.com/forums2/index.php?board=1;action=display;threadid=13885;start=msg236852#msg236852 and
http://www.golfclubatlas.com/forums2/index.php?board=1;action=display;threadid=21005;start=msg379597 * Westfields - a "Fred Couples" CCFAD that is not bordered by any homes
* Twin Lakes -- the muni where I keep my handicap, and down the street from Westfields. Two 18-hole layouts: the newer Oaks is more challenging and interesting, and plays a little tighter; the Lakes is more open but the greens are far less interesting. The Lakes is perfect for the bogey or worse golfer. Conditioning can be an issue, but the price is right and they always allow walking (most CCFADs in the DC area don't allow walking on a weekend morning). I've written about the Oaks course here before without anyone else commenting; I think it's incorrectly viewed as just another average muni.
Here's what I wrote previously about the Oaks:
I find that the Oaks offers the best combination of balanced holes, challenging but fair (especially for the mid handicapper like myself), decent pace of play (the Lakes tends to get a lower quality of golfer and therefore play slower), walkable, and attractive (no surrounding homes) that's within 30-40 minutes of where I live. The design is straight forward, with the occasional blind shot and bit of deception; the fairways are wide but trouble happens if you miss them by much (the Oaks is a fair title -- there are many heavily treed areas with thick underbrush). Greens have some slope, but putts that don't have an obvious big swing due tend to break less than you will read; these subtle breaks can make it tough for the first timer to score well. The course is not the toughest for a low handicapper, but quite difficult for the mid or high handicapper. The white tees ratings are 70.7/135 for 6316 yards (from the tips it plays 6700 yards witrh ratings of 72.5/137).
In the good-but-overrated/not-worth-the-money-or-effort category:
* Raspberry Falls
* Stonewall (you can see RTJ #18 from this course, I forget which hole)
* Augustine
In the category of interesting courses outside the 30-mile radius are two courses in the VA Blue Ridge and two near Frederick, MD:
* Shenandoah Valley Golf Club
* Virginia National
* Whiskey Creek
* Musket Ridge
My favorite place to play in the DC area is Shenandoah Valley GC, considering the price (highest fee is $50 on a weekend morning, as little as $12 to walk after 2 PM Mon-Thrs), good conditioning, generally a fast pace of play, a friendly staff, and the course itself: mountain-style course, no water hazards, no fairway bunkers, but tight, rolling fairways, smallish greens on the old 18 (larger greens on the newest 9), and a nice routing that provides variety. Plenty walkable unless it’s very hot and humid. May not be challenging enough for a very low handicapper, but it should provide enough interest for anyone else.
I haven't played every public course of note in the DC area; by reputation, PB Dye and Blue Ridge Shadows appear to be worth a look (and both are on my to-do list).