Michael D:
Please tell me what you see as the deficiencies with the course? If you think Tetherow can't "sniff(ing) the tailpipe of Pac Dunes then you must be smoking some very strong stuff with no disrespect. The idea that Bandon Trails is ahead is also misguided -- the middle section of that layout goes to zzzzz in a big time way. Bandon frankly, gets plenty of attention and has in some ways received a free pass from many because no one believes that other courses can equal or surpass them. Tetherow is better than two of them there and while I concede Pac Dunes is better the margin between them is far from the extreme you mentioned.
Like I said your detailed response is appreciated.
Matt
No need to browbeat me into engaging you in a discussion.
So....here is my "detailed response," not that it is going to matter anyways because you are going to think what you think and I am going to think what I think, regardless......
Interesting you've chosen to go the direction of asking me to point out the deficiencies of the Tetherow course in making a comparison to PD, BT et al. I just finished raving about Tetherow! It's a sweet course, I liked it a lot.
But let me count the ways it fails to live up to PD, for one.
A. Land is no contest. I probably like burnt-out desert more than the next guy but it's not linksland and cliffs above ocean.
B. Routing is no contest. PD has so many subtle nuances like the first three holes playing directly towards the ocean. The trek back inland, resurfacing back to the ocean and the march home. Tetherow has no "theme" the golf holes just kinda run all over the place, indeed going up and down the hill on 1, 9, 10 and 18.
C. The individual holes are not equal. Tetherow has some stunners to be sure, but at the end of the day I find them to lack the subtle sophistication that PD's possess. Things are a little too "tricked up" at Tetherow. I personally find it to be a fine line between integrating strategy into a hole and going over the top with this integration.
You may not agree, and that's fine, but please spare me any blathering about "totality."
A hole like #6 at Tetherow, for example, is overwhelming. I don't even know where to start breaking it down. On the other hand, a hole like #8 at Pacific Dunes grows on you; you realize there are many ways to solve the riddle, and one of them is to just pop it in the fairway and pop it on the green.
You rarely get that option at Tetherow, because on a lot of holes a standard two putt is just not feesible given hole locations.
Good old fashioned fairways and greens golf is an option at Pacific, it's not at Tetherow.
As per usual, I think you liked the course better because you are a good player. I could see it being more interesting if you could actually play a long iron and stop it on the hood of a car....from a blind landing zone....but I cannot.
To me, a great course adheres to the dictum of 'ol Dr. Mac, playable to the hack and challenging to the stud.