My New England 9 hole list would be:
*North Haven Golf Club ME -
http://golfclubatlas.com/forum/index.php/topic,25025.0.html*Edgartown GC - with better/restored greens would be neck and neck with North Haven
*Highland Links - have not actually played it, but saw a bunch. The views are dramatic, but I think Edgartown is a better course.
*Hay Harbor - Fishers Island - again did not play it but you can see most of it
*Fenwick GC - CT
*Hotchkiss GC - CT (with apologies to my friend Jim Kennedy)
*Mink Meadows GC - Martha's Vineyard
*Tarrantine GC ME
Perhaps the poster from maine will chime in.......
Edgartown was also in perfect condition. We had a great week of weather but they were coming off a bunch of rain and the course firmish.