3 weeks ago I had the opportunity to play Golspie in an Open competition. Whilst I have played the course many times in the past, this was the first vist for me in over 10 years. This hiatus had nothing to do with dissatisfaction with the course and everything to do with the time pressures of parenthood.
When I first played Golspie in the early 1980s I thought it was a fine course, but overrated vis a vis Brora (in those days--and even in some quarters today--the latter was felt to the be preferred "second course" to Dornoch). Now, however, since Brora has become a sanctified "hidden gem" and Golspie has been largely ignored, I think the relative overrating is the other way around.
Overall, Golspie has a seemingly unique combination of roughly 1/3 links holes, 1/2 heathand ones and a few parklandish types. Just about all through the course (maybe the 1st, 14th and 15th being excepted), the soil is sandy and springy and very conducive to good and interesting golf. The condition of the course, which informative rumors had considered to be spotty at best, is now excellent.
There are (and have always been) some superb golf holes. 2-5 are classic seaside holes, with the latter (a par 5) of particular interest given the blind 2nd shot which entails all sorts of risks and reward options, depending on your game and the weather. 6 heads back inland and with 2, 10, 16 and 17 comprises a group of par-3's that would be outstanding on any course. 7and 8 are more hard than appealing, each requiring a long and straight drive between the heather to avoid disaster and give hope to a par. 10-13 are fine heathland holes, where good players often play cautiously off the tee to avoid temptation. 14 is a slog, which has been lengthened, but not yet improved. 15 can grow upon you, particuarly the grass bunkers/"tattie pits" which guard the left side of the fairway. 16 and 17 played the same club for me even though their yardages were 175 and 215, respectively. Yes the wind does blow at Golspie. The 420 yard 18 is a bit goofy, but so is the last at Dornoch--both of them are puzzlements if you are looking for a par.
The bottom line? If you are in the Highland, by all means play Dornoch as often as you can and Brora for a break, but if you have some time and/or a sense of adventure, play Golspie too. It is, in fact the hidden gem of the area.