"And I'm still interested to see whether anyone thinks the WTF 8th hole is Bottle-like"
Mark, I'll bite. No, I don't believe it is Bottle-like. My sense of a Bottle is a choice right or left divided by a few bunkers roughly in the middle, with one side being easier to hit but leaving the tougher second shot. I don't get that with your wtf hole. From the rounds I have seen everyone tries to hit over the long bunker, and the choice is which line to choose of the infinite right to left options based on length.
PS I too like the 16 hole. It is graceful, and the dogleg bunker is well done and at a good distance.
My issue with your Eden hole is it softness--my ball has plugged on that green, and it would be so much better if having to account for the bounce and roll.
I am also a fan of #3. It has an impressive sense of scale, and though it plays long I find the shots inviting and interesting.
PPS Two more wtfs for me at Blue Mash--#1: Still have no sense of where to even aim on the tee, and #14; why did they forget to build a fairway?