Gib
Your tennis card is also overworn and marked (probably from being handled too often by Tom Paul's tobacco stained fingers...)
Assuming that the "golden age" of tennis was in the early Open era (~1968-1990), almost all of the biggest names (Laver, Newcombe, Smith, Ashe, Connors, Borg, Lendl and Becker, Edberg, Sampras) were power players. The only really good finesse players I can think of were Rosewall and McEnroe, but both could hit the crap out of the ball when they wanted to. There were of course Michael Chang and Harold ("moonball") Solomon but not too many people paid good money to watch those guys play.
And, as to the issue at hand, I think Finchem is right on this one. I have sympathy for the two guys that might be screwed out of a few tournaments a year by effectively being relegated to #s 126 and 127, but if they are really any good and have any gumption they make it anyway. Let's be honest, who other than their mothers and their high school buddies really cares about the guys who are only good enough to swim in the Ty Webb Memorial Pond of Mediocrity on the tour? Finchem isn't running an annual spelling bee, he's an impressario (although probably the least charismatic one in memory). Duval will sell far more tickets and satisfy more sponsors over his lifetime than 95% of the players on the tour. And, by adding Dudley to the extension list, he shows (as Peter P has said above) he's got heart.
Rich