Jim -
To be clear, I think rough and trees are both bad ideas, but but if you are committed to travel down that road, trees are worse than rough. For the reasons given above.
I simply don't buy the idea that trees are a less permanent feature than rough.
I also don't understand how the following are not opposites:
Club A wants more trees. Club B wants fewer trees.
Whatever the frequency with which Club A and Club B hold major tournaments, those are opposite views on the tree issue. If they aren't, I want a full refund on the sentential logic course I took in college.
Bob