Rick -
I have a very different take on Davis and the whole idea of judging performance.
I believe people are too wowed by length, ball striking ability and stats. The real talent, the real gift, is the ability to win, which usually means (quite obviously) shooting the lowest score that matters at that time.
I don't think this is something that is entirely work related, nor do I believe it's something that is effort related. As evidence, I say look at Tiger at The Masters last year. Arguably the greatest player ever, unquestionably the greatest player and winner of the last 30 years, Tiger himself said he never wanted to win a tournament as badly as he wanted to win The Masters last year, due to his father's failing health. His caddie Steve Williams said he's never seen Tiger try as hard to win a tournament. He quite obviously didn't. Did he fail? Not by my standards, he just didn't win. I feel the same way about a lot of Davis's play.
When it comes to evaluating DLIII's career, I think people need to take a good long look at just how deep the competition is these days. Forget how effortlessly he hits the ball a mile, just look at what it takes to win. And, most importantly, don't be warped by the inhuman standard that Tiger has set. If Tiger hadn't come along, people would be speculating as to whether a career like Davis's, Phil's, Ernie's, Vijay's, Freddie's, etc., would be now as good a career as anyone would ever have again.
-----
As for Davis's views on architecture, I encourage everyone to read his heartfelt book,
Every Shot I Take. He discusses his views on gca a bit, even relates a few stories about his burgeoning business.
The other thing to take note of is Paul Cowley's (paul cowley?
) posts. In spite of his self-deprecating attempts to portray himself otherwise, he is one of the most insightful and thoughtful posters on the site. He's kind of like the east coast version of Slag - almost every post reeks of a pure insight that most can only dream of attaining. The fact that he would choose to work with Davis speaks volumes of the man's judgement, imho.
Thanks for posting the link to the interview, Steve.