There have been several times when I suspected that Jay Flemma was full of shit.
In particular, he has certaintly misused or misunderstood the phrase "line of charm," which, by the way, I only believe I understand because of some postings here.
But, people have gone beyond the pale here, criticizing Jay because people think he's a higher handicap golfer.
Well, that's not kosher--a higher handicap player can evaluate a course, including how that course plays for others, just as well as a lower handicap player.
I've disagreed with Jay many times, but I think people on this thread have been disrespectful and out of line.
Jay may be on to something that Dismal River is too hard for the middle handicap player--I don't know because I haven't played it.
In any event, I'm coming to Jay's defense because most of the people attacking him here haven't played DR either--they're just defending DR for some unknown reason.
Listen, I don't have a dog in this fight, and Jay's criticism of DR may be right or wrong, but it's not wrong simply because he may have a higher handicap than you.