Paul,
The maintainance merits TEPaul alludes to are largely determined by Mother Nature.
The architectural merits are numerous and substantive.
Newport also enjoys a catalyst for highlighting those merits, the WIND.
I'm a big fan of Newport as it existed when I played it, before fairways were narrowed.
I found it to be a very sporty and challenging golf course that was a great deal of fun to play.
Holes # 1 and 12 played from different tees as either long par 4's or shorter par 5's. I liked that flexibility, especially on a windy site.
Newport has two of the most interesting back to back par 3's.
They're so WILDLY different, which makes playing them back to back a unique experience.
If my friend Eddie Ricci wouldn't park his car behind # 13 green it could become a skyline green.
It's a great golf course, one of those that meets the "play it every day and love it" test.