Tom.
Based on what you are looking for I would ditto Rich's advice. The El Tigre course is in Nuevo Vallarta.
McClosky. Apologize, if I implied Marina Vallarta was superior to Punta Mita. I didn't think I did. I confess that I only played the Punta Mita course once, but I stand by my memory that it was nothing special. I remember some beautiful ocean views, but I also remember uninteresting, undefined fairways. The resort was certainly peaceful and elegant, but I did not factor that in to the golf course. I can't remember how I scored, but I certainly enjoyed playing there with my son.
I also stand by my assessment of Isla Navidad. Sorry you didn't find it that good and particularly apologise if you travelled there on my advice and got to that conclusion.