Rich,
Reading your post, and then your "My Home Course" feature reminded me of the most raging debate of our trip -- on #17 at Dornoch, is it better to lay up on the upper level to get a clear view of the green, or to blast it over the hill to get a shorter, but blind, shot in?
I opted for the upper level, and pulled it into a gorse bush. One of my companions went for the longer shot, didn't turn it over, and drove it through everything into whins, etc. So much for strategy if you can't execute...seriously though, what is the prevailing view amongst the members?