Sorry I had to bail out on the Sunday get together. My brother had a 6 pm flight back home to Oregon and our 5 pm drink was not a timely thing! Hopefully next time.
I absolutely loved Apache Stronghold, with TSN not far behind. The fact that you could walk both was certainly a plus. We played AS on Friday, TSN on Sunday, and Desert Mountain/Apache on Saturday as a guest of the pro. DM/A is lush, nice course, homes pretty close on both sides, cart ball, can't remember any of the holes except the dual-green par 5 (why would anybody play the short/no bunker option?).
With regard to conditions at AS: they are making progress. I haven't seen how it was before last year, but I didn't have a big problem with this year's fairways. I had to bump the ball maybe 20% of the time, usually played it down. There were some weeds which needed to be excised, but I think budget is a problem given how cheap the deal is up there. I heard from a guy in the shop that they are giving up on the bluegrass and overseeding with bermuda in the fall and hoping to make that the dominant grass. What a bunch of great golf holes; I can remember the entire layout and remember none of Desert Mountain.
By contrast, I was put off by the pristine condition of Talking Stick. They've overseeded the fairways with ryegrass, and I found the course played longer at 6500 middle tees than AS played at 7000 and DM/A at 6800. Very little roll, and not much firmness in front of the greens. But it's a great ground game design, there was always a shot on the ground but usually you had to hit it harder than you wanted to and I came up short a lot. The glory of that course is the great set of bunkers, deep, steep, great shadow effects, and great tie in to the native grasses on the outside of the fairway bunkers. Those bunkers are a tutorial! I particularly loved the carry bunker on #4, the center bunkers on #5 and #18, and the bunkers short left on #18. The par 3 #11 ("Brassie"), what a super long par 3.
I'll be posting on the Discussion Board about the whole trip. Sorry we couldn't discuss it in person.
Regards,
Bill McBride