Cary, While not within your request route, Eagle Point (Rees) and Running Y Ranch(Palmer) are possible, given thier proximity and quality. Eagle Point came highly reccomended and I regret not getting there. Running Y Ranch is just above Klamath Falls and IMO was prettier than Tahoe, and has reasonable real estate prices. If your still looking to get out of hurricane alley.
Ashland Oregon is a real treat, hosting the Shakespere Festival and many fine dining alternatives. Reminiscent of Carmel, Ca. at, at least, 50% off.