Shouldn't there be some weighting in this for the size of the state? If PA and NJ are fairly close in quality, shouldn't NJ get the nod? And, if we consider quality gcs per square mile, what about Washington DC? I know it's not a state but it's surrounded by states and has its own government, income tax, police, and license plates.
DC has 4 courses with great histories - Rock Creek (Flynn), East Potomac Park (36 holes from Robert White and possibly Walter Travis as well as one of the country's first miniature golf courses), Langston (Wm Gordon). And for those worrying about access - they are all public and inexpensive with no extra charges for non-residents. There is a fifth course at Ft. McNair - just across from East Potomac Park - but since its on a military reservation within DC, it doesn't count. I'm not sure about access either. If any of you would like to get on, send me an IM and I'll see what I can do.
Craig-
Hmm...I like your opinion, but you know as well as I do, DC's public golf courses do suffer from poor conditioning and obvious neglect.
The private clubs are overall good, but nowhere near the strength of the areas up Interstate 95.
Having said that, if several things were different, you would have several architects represented in a small area; think about this: Travis (Columbia, EPP), Ross (Orig. Indian Spring, orig. WG&CC), Flynn (several redesigns, orig. Beaver Dam, Manor, orig. Woodmont, Friendship, and several others within a short distance), Emmet (Congressional), Colt/Alison (Burning Tree, Chevy Chase), and a great Tillinghast a short distance away in Baltimore CC.
I know Prince George's was supposed to be great as well.
The thing is, because of poor planning, management, ownership, etc, a lot of these courses are NLE
and others have been altered or are on the block as we speak (I can almost see the steam coming from Craig Disher's ears right now!), in comparison to other metropolitan areas in the East, such as the greater NY/NJ area, Phila, and Boston, to name several.
From my understanding, in the immediate DC area, I would say only Columbia and Burning Tree are probably the closest to the original designs/original layouts, from what I know. There undoubtedly have been some changes, but not to the marked effect other courses have experienced.