Biarritz:
As wonderful a golf course as Fishers Island truly is, I wouldn't call the 2nd hole there a particularly "great" Redan. Because of the shallow water table, digging deeper bunkers wasn't/isn't an option at Fishers. Building the green UP 2-4 feet might have been interesting but it wasn't done that way.
"Alps", "Eden", "Cape" and, especially, "Biarritz" are excellent renditions at Fishers - in class with the originals in my view. "Redan" is a fine hole but there are several mucho better examples IMO (Somerset Hills, Shinnecock and, of course, NGLA come to mind). Haven't played the others you mentioned (yet).
The reverse Redan at the Links Golf Club was a wonderful hole and tough, too - 190-205 slightly uphill with little probability of a helping breeze.
Although not a par 3, my nominee for "best" hole in all of golf (#6 at The Creek) has a wonderful reverse Redan green complex.
By contrast, the Redan at The Greenbrier's Old White Course is a disappointment.